Huge rant
I am not anti-natalist at all and I am not making a case for such reactionary ideologies here. Just sharing what I have seen so other folks and point my mistakes or just listen.
I am witnessing the older cousins of my generation in the family have and raise kids and it is a little bit terrifying. I am talking about two couples of parents, each with one child. The older kid is about 3 years old and the younger one is about 1 year old.
The older kid does almost nothing but throw tantrums all day. It is near impossible to make them do anything they do not want to do. For example, making them sit down in their high chair and eat the food they are being fed is a Herculean task. The child has to be distracted somehow. Two things that I saw that work:
- Put on YouTube videos on an iPad. These videos are like crack-cocaine for a child’s brain BTW. The creators are highly incentivised to make the videos as addictive as possible to boost their ad revenue.
- Have someone play with them. The kid seemed to like me because I was new to them and I made them laugh, so they would sometimes allow their parents to feed them as long as I played with them.
The other child, who is a year old, is starting to exhibit similar behaviour. In the morning and afternoon, they are looked after by their grandparents. Their grandfather is responsible for feeding them. The grandfather is a boomer addicted to cable TV news and the stock market. (Cable TV news in India is BTW extremely garbage and inflicts incalculable amounts of psychic damage. There are no words to describe how bad it is.) As he feeds the child, the child sits on his lap watching the TV while being spoonfed. On the other hand, if the child is sitting on a high chair with no distractions, they refuse to eat even as the one who feeds them talks to them. The child does drink milk from the bottle without fuss so I am not sure whether they are in a descend towards problematic behaviour or not.
I don’t have the knowledge or experience to confidently say whether things have to be this way or not so I don’t want to jump to passing judgement on the child’s parents and definitely not on the child. Maybe it is just how it is. Maybe children just throw tantrums while being subjected to feeding. Maybe TV or YouTube videos have nothing to do with it. I admittedly do not like technology as it is sold to us so my cynicism definitely comes a biased standpoint.
Mostly it got me wondering though how there are no public services to help with parenting, which is a foundationally important task for not just the well-being of society, but also perpetuating it. For example, I was wondering if crack-cocaine-tier addictive YouTube videos for children are detrimental to the child’s growth and the overall experience of parenting. This is the year 2023 and I am pretty sure god knows how many tens of thousands of work-hours must have been put into researching issues like this. To find out, I can try using a search engine and hope to god that I don’t get ratfucked by dishonest or just low quality articles that have been pushed to the top of the results through SEO. If I am savvy, I can try searching directly for research on something like Google Scholar but very few people are capable of this. (Not even me.) I found a pediatric psychologist who has made it her life’s work to extol the vices of electronic media addiction on children. She sells books and courses on this which makes me trust her a little bit less since she profits off of it. She could be a charlatan feeding off of technophobe parents’ paranoia. There are pediatric associations in every country but their findings and recommendations don’t reach the masses. I have heard some advertisements from my country’s on the radio. But they are few and far between and not in-depth at all. This kind of knowledge is still mostly passed from parents to their children instead of being rooted deeper in collective scientific findings.
Electronic media, social media, and their effects on the brain and habits is something that I am maybe overly sensitive about. My brain has been fried by a combination of anxiety and social media addiction to the point that I really struggle to read books because of being attention deficit. The children’s parents and grandparents are also hooked to their phones and TVs. But since they are comfortably upper middle class and with generational wealth, they do not introspect their habits and life choices because having wealth in a capitalist society means you are doing good so you don’t need to change what you are doing. The only things you can do better are what will net you more wealth.
Lastly, the parents don’t seem to find it problematic that they don’t get the chance to spend much time with their child even if they wanted to. All these parents are employed and working, so they work most of the day and delegate childcare to the grandparents and nannies who are poor and underpaid. One of the mothers, did not even get paid maternal leave despite working at one of the biggest private hospital chains. She had to quit the job and find a new one when the child was just six months old. I feel like if I had a child, I would want to take care of them almost full time at least until they are a year old and likely even older. It feels terrible to delegate childcare to an underpaid servant.
I don’t have a larger point to make because I was just ranting. I don’t feel qualified to hold strong opinions in this realm. Parenting I feel is always going to be tough. I cannot imagine it being programmatic and straightforward to raise human beings with all their complexities. The problem for me is that there are no public institutions to try and make this easier. Parents are left to their own devices, like getting their child hooked to addictive YouTube video channels, or finding an underpaid slave that ends up spending more time taking care of your child than her own to be able to put food on the table, or maybe paying for an expensive private daycare so you can slave away and the execs at your company can buy their seventh yacht.
While I’m not trying to convince anyone to have kids, the idea that “they are not your kids anymore after age 6” is completely false. Yes, they learn different things from their friend group, and yes, some of those things are detrimental, but to a large extent, if your kids are abandoning the things you taught immediately upon teaching primary school, then that’s on the parent. Maybe it’s just our kids, but when they were younger, we spent countless hours explaining why certain rules existed, practicing and reinforcing empathy, and teaching them how to be excited about learning.
I’m not naïve enough to think that they will always behave the way I think is appropriate or believe the same things I believe, but after having two kids get to the preteen age, I am confident that the core of our teachings continue to be a foundational piece of who they are. And that’s ok.
Plus, it’s not like they magically stop needing help at age 7. They still don’t know how to be a functioning person and they still need parents to talk to them and help them understand the world around them. If someone honestly thought that their kids “stop being [their] kids at age six or seven,” that personally makes me think that the parent is just looking for an excuse to give up and check out (or they don’t realize how much of what’s happening is a direct result of their own parenting decisions). Sure it’s hard. Sure, there are days when I just want to phone it in and let someone or something else do the parenting by sticking the kids in front of a screen. But I think that my kids’ minds are valuable and I want to be a part of their lives and worldviews, so it’s on me to make that happen.
That’s why we ask about their days and listen when they answer, so we know what’s going on with their friend groups. It’s why we limit screen time and when we do watch screens, most times it’s as a family watching the same thing, so we can build shared experiences. It’s why we drive them to their athletic events hours away and sit and watch them rather than just send them with their friends’ parents, so we can show then that we value the things they work hard for (and to reinforce that we will reward hard work and enthusiasm with our time and attention). If parents don’t do these things as early and as often as possible, of course kids are going to look elsewhere for guidance and approval.
Not sure who downvoted you and why. I think a parent as an adult should definitely possibly be able to win an oratorship contest against their child’s peers who are less than ten years old.
There must be a method of communicating to children as an adult. There must be somewhat of a science to it as well.
Disclaimer: I have no idea what I’m talking about
Ehh, some people could have taken my response as an attack on their loved ones or their own parenting style.
Definitely. And I should clarify; by no means am I saying that my kids are perfect or you will have zero behavioral issues if you spend time with your kids. My kids have their issues like anyone else learning how to be a person from scratch. But talking things through and engaging with your kids from ages 0-5 should mean that the impact of your words is significantly more than their peers. It shouldn’t come down to a debate between a parent and a 9yo peer. By the time they get to school, your kids should already understand your family’s values and expectations on some level, even if their understanding is as simple as the Golden Rule and empathy for others.
I want my kids to be their own people, but I want to be helping them learn and engaging with them to the point that they can practically hear their parents as part of their inner monologue.
Assuming that you’re interested in helping your cousins and their kids, you are absolutely in a position to learn and help your relatives. While being a cousin or aunt or uncle is always going to be way different than being a parent, one of the best things you can do to help your cousins and their kids is to just engage and treat them like their people. They might not know much yet, but kids as young as 2 can tell when people coddle them, ignore them, or condescend to them. Talk to them and play with them like they’re real people and you’ll be amazed at how much they respond. Plus, IMHO all kids need an adult that they can talk to that’s not their parents (especially once they hit ages 10+), so if you start taking an interest, talking to them, and playing with them now, then you may find that you become that cool young adult figure in a way that can really help them out down the road. At the very least, you can start to see what not to do (as you have already started to notice), so that if you ever do become a parent, you can do it better.