spoiler
  • The Witness was once an entire species
  • They discovered the Traveler buried on their home planet.
  • The Traveler uplifted their civilization and basically they got bored and needed purpose.
  • This led them to seek out The Veil. They built the pyramid ships to search for the Veil.
  • The Veil is the Darkness equivalent of the Traveler. Not the pyramid ships.
  • The Witness saw the light as a chaotic force to be tamed and tried to use the darkness/Veil to tame it and create the final shape.
  • Traveler said nope and began running.
  • The Witness’ race mass suicided and used the Darkness to combine their consciousness into what we know as The Witness.
  • All the crumbling statues around the pyramids are the remains of its species.

Some pretty dark stuff with the origins of the Witness. I don’t think it’s quite clear what the final shape is yet.

  • @draecasEnglish
    2•1 year ago

    I can totally get behind telling a story over the entire year. The problem is they didn’t bother with a story that would do well doled out in parts. Instead they went “Let’s just return to D1 poorly explained mcguffins and then we can explain it later!” which backfired horribly.

    • @jontree255OPMEnglish
      4•1 year ago

      MyNameIsByf put out a vid on it today with I think valid criticism. His main points:

      • The content of the story and the actual story are not bad. (I agree, otherwise I wouldn’t have posted it)
      • The delivery of the story beats is bad.
      • The conscious decision to exclude this from Lightfall was a bad decision. (Season 21 was all but finished before Lightfall shipped)
      • This cutscene should have been in Lightfall and probably would have saved the narrative.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W02W44H30kA

      • @draecasEnglish
        2•1 year ago

        Great video for sure. Yeah the actual story revealed is fine. I don’t care that the Veil is still largely mysterious because we’ve given it the context where that mystery doesn’t matter as much – it’s the darkness analogue to the traveller. It seems to be singular, gives out(?) darkness powers. There’s still plenty of mystery (wtf are the traveller and the veil? are they sentient in any way? we’ve seen some signs of it from the traveller but nothing I’d call definitive yet, as examples), but we understand where the veil sits in the story and why we needed to prevent the Witness from geting in there (OOPS!)