Discovery lacked the DNA of other Star Trek in my opinion. Note that I did not finish the series so some of these things may have improved in the last season or 2.
It focused mainly around a few characters instead of fleshing out a great ensemble cast
The visual language of the show does not match Trek IMO. It’s too dark, too much blue, it looks like a Michael Bay thing
The characters did not feel like professional officers. Excess PDA, emotional outbursts, cowboy lone hero nonsense, snark, overt arguments, constantly raised voices, etc. In previous Trek, raised emotions were exceedingly notable, and meant something really important was happening
The klingons
I didn’t like many of the characters as people, including most of the main cast’s characters
There were things I did like
Great premise with the spore drive
I liked some of the characters, like Stamets and Saru
Great SFX
I’m sure I’m forgetting things, it’s been a while since I’ve thought about this show
4/10
Discovery lacked the DNA of other Star Trek in my opinion. Note that I did not finish the series so some of these things may have improved in the last season or 2.
There were things I did like
I’m sure I’m forgetting things, it’s been a while since I’ve thought about this show