Well, if you’d like, I can point out WHY it’s a straw man, but you seem to have a grasp on that bit, however…
It’s a straw man because you’re asserting that a centrist would immediately want hear out a deeply biased corporation with nothing but profit motivation and would weigh them the same.
If you wanted the example to be more accurate and like the current US political system, instead of presenting the Democrats as disconnected neutral parties with nothing to gain, they would be akin to vaping corporations and the centrist would tell them both to get fucked (all the while tobacco users and bros with “sick vape rigs” called them stupid because “at least they stand for something”).
If you wanted the example to be more accurate and like the current US political system, instead of presenting the Democrats as disconnected neutral parties with nothing to gain, they would be akin to vaping corporations and the centrist would tell them both to get fucked
I have to assume leaving Republican out of that paragraph was a typo, otherwise that argument is not centrist at all.
If Republican was meant to be in there then I guess not listening to either political party is fair, but those are your voting options so I don’t know how you manage that. Typically when I hear people talk about being a centrist it’s in regards to an argument Democrats and Republicans are having, so even if “telling both parties to get fucked” is true for you, it’s not true for most “centrists” people encounter.
There’s also the fact that compared to the rest of the world Democrats are “slightly right” on the political spectrum and Republicans are “extreme right”. So someone close to the center on the political spectrum would be further left than Democrats. When I hear someone say they are a “Centrist” followed by saying “maybe the Republican supporters have a point” it rings hollow.
Well, if you’d like, I can point out WHY it’s a straw man, but you seem to have a grasp on that bit, however…
It’s a straw man because you’re asserting that a centrist would immediately want hear out a deeply biased corporation with nothing but profit motivation and would weigh them the same.
If you wanted the example to be more accurate and like the current US political system, instead of presenting the Democrats as disconnected neutral parties with nothing to gain, they would be akin to vaping corporations and the centrist would tell them both to get fucked (all the while tobacco users and bros with “sick vape rigs” called them stupid because “at least they stand for something”).
I have to assume leaving Republican out of that paragraph was a typo, otherwise that argument is not centrist at all.
If Republican was meant to be in there then I guess not listening to either political party is fair, but those are your voting options so I don’t know how you manage that. Typically when I hear people talk about being a centrist it’s in regards to an argument Democrats and Republicans are having, so even if “telling both parties to get fucked” is true for you, it’s not true for most “centrists” people encounter.
There’s also the fact that compared to the rest of the world Democrats are “slightly right” on the political spectrum and Republicans are “extreme right”. So someone close to the center on the political spectrum would be further left than Democrats. When I hear someone say they are a “Centrist” followed by saying “maybe the Republican supporters have a point” it rings hollow.
The assumption on my part was that the evil tobacco corp (the only other party in your example) was the stand in for the Republicans.