Personally I think it is all posturing. It’s Texas tough talk. While I think at some point it may be beneficial to leave the union, we are not there yet.
The benefits would be that they would not be tied to the federal government any longer. Texas is a large enough state to go on its own. It is larger than many European countries. As such they wouldn’t be burned with politics they don’t like.
The detriment would be they would no longer be Americans, many of the large companies may leave since America could put tariffs on their products. They could also have a brain drain since many people would want to stay American.
We have a large divide in this country but I don’t think it’s to the point of breaking up but that is just my opinion.
ETA: In my opinion, there are more cons than pros right now to leaving.
Does the UK’s experience with Brexit, where they were legally allowed to leave, give you pause for thought that you may have vastly underestimated the problems secession might cause?
Yes Texas has a large economy but a good chunk of that is Federal institutions Defence, NASA etc and the companies that support them. The rest is also US companies.
The Texas economy would take a catastrophic hit even if it was allowed to leave peacefully.
Defence, Texas would have none as the DOD would leave and take everything with them.
As I said I don’t support them leaving but I also don’t live in Texas. I think one of the rights of the people is to decide if they want to stay in a union. It is a check against a tyrannical government.
As I pointed out, that would be one of the concerns. American companies would have to decide if they want Texas or America.
DOD wouldn’t be able to take everything. Texas owns the National Guard.
This is something Texas has talked about for years. I think it is just talk.
Just what the USA needs another civil war over secession.
Personally I think it is all posturing. It’s Texas tough talk. While I think at some point it may be beneficial to leave the union, we are not there yet.
What benefits do you see from leaving?
And for balance.
What detriments do you see from leaving?
The benefits would be that they would not be tied to the federal government any longer. Texas is a large enough state to go on its own. It is larger than many European countries. As such they wouldn’t be burned with politics they don’t like.
The detriment would be they would no longer be Americans, many of the large companies may leave since America could put tariffs on their products. They could also have a brain drain since many people would want to stay American.
We have a large divide in this country but I don’t think it’s to the point of breaking up but that is just my opinion.
ETA: In my opinion, there are more cons than pros right now to leaving.
Does the UK’s experience with Brexit, where they were legally allowed to leave, give you pause for thought that you may have vastly underestimated the problems secession might cause?
Yes Texas has a large economy but a good chunk of that is Federal institutions Defence, NASA etc and the companies that support them. The rest is also US companies.
The Texas economy would take a catastrophic hit even if it was allowed to leave peacefully.
Defence, Texas would have none as the DOD would leave and take everything with them.
As I said I don’t support them leaving but I also don’t live in Texas. I think one of the rights of the people is to decide if they want to stay in a union. It is a check against a tyrannical government.
As I pointed out, that would be one of the concerns. American companies would have to decide if they want Texas or America.
DOD wouldn’t be able to take everything. Texas owns the National Guard.
This is something Texas has talked about for years. I think it is just talk.