• @Doorbook
      link
      4810 months ago

      Bush: Iraq and Afghanistan… Obama: Syria, Yemen, Sudan, Libya Joe: Palestine


      Then USA media be like: Why there are terrorists in the Middle East and why they attack the Uniyed States…

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        710 months ago

        Same for the migrants from all the south American countries we destroyed or made unstable.

        we make their home unlivable why are they coming here

      • @DoomBot5
        link
        English
        -1110 months ago

        Just adding to this as a reminder. Hamas kidnapped American citizens as part of the 200+ hostages.

        • @Maggoty
          link
          17
          edit-2
          10 months ago

          Yes they obviously hate our way of life. The way that includes selling weapons to the colonial state blockading them.

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            910 months ago

            And providing billions unconditionally. Like seriously, unconditionally? Like they could kill tens, hundreds of thousands, a million, and you’d still fund that? Biden deserves a shit stain or ten on his name.

            • @DoomBot5
              link
              English
              010 months ago

              Providing billions on condition it’s spent at US military companies is not the definition of unconditionally.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          1010 months ago

          I wonder why so many foreign citizens got caught up in this… certainly not because there’s so many settlers who came to help colonize. Couldn’t be it.

          • @DoomBot5
            link
            English
            -610 months ago

            Maybe they were at a party when Hamas murdered and kidnapped them?

          • BraveSirZaphod
            link
            fedilink
            -1310 months ago

            The land immediately outside Gaza has been recognized as Israel proper since the 40s, and it has never been included as part of any proposal for a Palestinian state.

            So, unless your actual aim is the complete eradication of Israel entirely, there’s no real grounds for criticism there. And if your aim is indeed the forced elimination of all Israelis, don’t bother pretending to care about peace.

            • NoneOfUrBusiness
              link
              fedilink
              1310 months ago

              Palestinians gave up on the land inside Israel’s 1949 borders, but that doesn’t mean it wasn’t ethnically cleansed as part of Israel’s colonial project. See: The Nakba. Politically pursuing them is impossible, but that doesn’t mean the people who “settled” them aren’t complicit in Israel’s genocide.

              • BraveSirZaphod
                link
                fedilink
                -610 months ago

                I don’t think any of the people involved in the Nakba are alive anymore, beyond perhaps a few dinosaurs in nursing homes.

                I’ll be the first to admit that the founding of Israel was a disastrously messy process that, frankly, probably shouldn’t have happened, and certainly shouldn’t have happened the way it did. But the fact of the matter is that it happened, Israel is here now, and there are generations of Israelis that have known no other home (most of whom are not of European heritage, it should be said).

                I’d agree that there were very real historical wrongs that need to be accounted for, but that won’t happen with the Israeli right dreaming of eliminating all Palestinians or Palestinians hoping to eliminate all Jews and destroy Israel. A random Israeli civilian living near Gaza is no more responsible for the Nakba than a random American today is for the ethnic cleaning of the Americas, and there is absolutely no pretense for random violence against them (just as there is zero pretense for West Bank settler violence against Palestinians).

                • prole
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  510 months ago

                  I don’t think any of the people involved in the Nakba are alive anymore

                  Yet you’re using arbitrary lines drawn after WW2…

                  • BraveSirZaphod
                    link
                    fedilink
                    -310 months ago

                    And you’re referring to land seizures that happened even earlier, so I’m not really sure what your point is.

                • NoneOfUrBusiness
                  link
                  fedilink
                  210 months ago

                  I don’t think any of the people involved in the Nakba are alive anymore, beyond perhaps a few dinosaurs in nursing homes.

                  Yet the effects continue to this day, in the form of an overpopulated Gaza and 6 million Palestinian exiles.

                  I don’t think any of the people involved in the Nakba are alive anymore, beyond perhaps a few dinosaurs in nursing homes.

                  A random Israeli civilian living near Gaza is no more responsible for the Nakba than a random American today is for the ethnic cleaning of the Americas,

                  No, because the Nakba continued. People continued to be expelled from their lands after 1949. It’s like someone moving to live on ancestral Native land that was taken three decades ago. I’m not saying all of them are criminals, but anyone who wasn’t born there is the same as West Bank settlers.

                  • BraveSirZaphod
                    link
                    fedilink
                    -110 months ago

                    Well, 70% of Israelis were born there, and most immigrant Jews go to firmly Jewish lands, so the odds of any random Israeli being a foreigner who came to settle traditionally Arab lands is quite small, though they do exist of course, and are rather shitty.

                    Regardless, the attacks on October 7th were concentrated on the land immediately surrounding Gaza, which has been firmly Jewish since the 40s. No Palestinian peace plan has ever claimed them. So even if you accept that direct violence is acceptable against people explicitly displacing Arabs, that describes essentially no victims of the attacks.

        • @alvvayson
          link
          710 months ago

          And Hamas actually wants to return them, but Netanyahu doesn’t want to negotiate and would rather flood the tunnels and kill them all.

          • @halferect
            link
            410 months ago

            Kinda… hamas wants to exchange for people for some known terrorists, some are just kids throwing rocks but some are hamas main line terrorists

            • NoneOfUrBusiness
              link
              fedilink
              1310 months ago

              Not just “some” are kids throwing rocks. Setting aside the Israeli justice system’s ability to fairly judge Palestinians, there are thousands of Palestinians being held without trial.

          • @samokosik
            link
            -310 months ago

            Sorry but what? If Hamas wants to return them, why did they take them in the first place?

            • NoneOfUrBusiness
              link
              fedilink
              810 months ago

              Because hostages are one of the few ways Hamas has to get concessions out of Israel. Those usually include freeing Palestinian political prisoners and loosening the blockade.

              • @Doorbook
                link
                010 months ago

                Don’t bother these people don’t even read news and will go through hoops to justify the IDF report of killing people at the rave party to not be taking hostage.

          • @DoomBot5
            link
            English
            -410 months ago

            Really? Hamas wants to return them? Is that why they couldn’t produce any more hostages that weren’t raped, beaten, or dead?

              • @DoomBot5
                link
                English
                -110 months ago

                “I went through hell,” Lifshitz said at a hospital in Tel Aviv early Tuesday.

                Her captors beat her in the ribs with sticks, she said, making it difficult to breathe. She was visibly exhausted and physically worn. But she told reporters that she offered the handshake because the Hamas militants “were gentle with us” while she was imprisoned in the “spiderweb” of tunnels under the Gaza Strip.

                Stockholm Syndrome textbook example right there. Kidnapped and beaten by Hamas, but thanked them afterwards.

                I don’t know where you’re getting anything from that article that says Hamas wants to return hostages. This was part of the ceasfire agreement Hamas broke.

        • Maeve
          link
          fedilink
          -510 months ago

          How many did ksa kill on 9/11? How many Saudis did we kill when we invaded ksa? See how that works?