What does this verse mean? The urine of a female (child) should be washed and the urine of a male (child) should be sprinkled over until the age of eating. (Sunan Abi Dawud 377)

@i_have_no_enemies · 10 months ago

What does this verse mean? The urine of a female (child) should be washed and the urine of a male (child) should be sprinkled over until the age of eating. (Sunan Abi Dawud 377)

??? · edit-2 10 months ago

What throws me off is that Jariyah جارية could either mean a young slave woman/girl or a girl who “has not reached the age”. Ghulam غلام could sometimes we used in the same way. So is it servant/slave boys and girls or children? 😬

Edit: BTW check out Hadith 336 from Ibi Dawood: https://sunnah.com/abudawud:376

Yeah, I guess they meant children and you understood the Hadith correctly. Girl piss = bad. Boy piss = No biggy.

Could be related to the relative clonesness of the female urinary track to the vagina? 😬

@i_have_no_enemies · edit-2 10 months ago

clearly women empowerment but then why does he say that all sorts of urine are equal (if it wasn’t added later?)

??? · 10 months ago

That part is a mystery to me 🤣 really not sure why it adds that statement that contradicts both Hadiths in the end.