Permanently Deleted

  • gregorum
    link
    fedilink
    English
    510 months ago

    If the Bible is the immutable word of your god, then what sense does it make to be able to cherry pick what parts to follow and what not to?

    • @kaitco
      link
      -110 months ago

      It’s not the Bible that’s the issue, but our current understanding of it.

      The Bible is generally broken into the laws, the histories, the lamentations, and words of promise all in the Old Testament and then the words and actions of Jesus and His followers in the New Testament.

      For Christians, the laws aren’t so much hard laws as much as they are “Tips for a Better Life, featuring the Prequel Stories”. The New Testament is what makes Christianity, and those texts primarily focus on the Grace of God, which is - hastily summarizing here - “All ‘sin’ requires the shedding blood, but I’ve already done that and forgiven everything, so just do your best”.

      Different gospels say different things about the same events. Different letters are written to different ancient churches by different people about many different issues. Different texts and histories are included or discarded dependent upon how any particular sect of Christianity worships. The Bible is a collection of the words of people who are driven by God for their purpose at their time, and so it is always going to be subject to adaptable understandings.

      All this is because mortal, imperfect people are in charge of interpreting, translating, and communicating the words of an entity that “exists” outside the confines of matter, energy, space, or time. As time continues, our understanding of the word adapts and changes.

      • gregorum
        link
        fedilink
        English
        310 months ago

        This sounds like a great argument for not taking anything the Bible says seriously at all.

        • @kaitco
          link
          110 months ago

          There’s nothing that forces you to take anything spiritual “seriously”. It’s up to you to make that decision for yourself.

          • gregorum
            link
            fedilink
            English
            110 months ago

            The Bible says you should, and most churches say you should.

        • Zloubida
          link
          010 months ago

          Or seriously enough to think about it, not just swallow everything. Christianity is a religion who praised critical thinking for centuries because the Bible is a book which should be studied. It was written by intelligent people who made a point to let contradictions and diverse points of view in order to let the reader decide.

          • gregorum
            link
            fedilink
            English
            1
            edit-2
            10 months ago

            Only for as long as nobody knew any better. It’s also a religion that put people like Galileo in jail, for daring to think differently. And burn them alive at the stake. Unless we forget the Spanish inquisition, or the crusades?

            • Zloubida
              link
              010 months ago

              Galileo was Christian as much as the Pope who condemned him.

    • Zloubida
      link
      -210 months ago

      The Bible isn’t the immutable word of God. The Word of God is Jesus-Christ. That’s what taught Christianity for 19 centuries before American evangelicalism invented the heresy of biblical inerrancy.