• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    98 months ago

    So, I know where you’re coming from because I’ve read stuff by Edmund Burke and other conservatives. But, unless the conservative you’re talking with is the intellectual type, they probably haven’t. They’ve probably just internalized some version of social conservatism but would also be appalled that you’d accuse them of supporting social stratification even as they support it.

    I learned some time ago that this particular argumentative strategy is incredibly pointless. They don’t care that you know the historical and philosophical foundation of their beliefs. For them, that foundation isn’t there for them. They probably don’t know it! Their life experiences inform them more than anything else.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      78 months ago

      They don’t care that you know the historical and philosophical foundation of their beliefs. For them, that foundation isn’t there for them. They probably don’t know it!

      Hold on, this came back into my mind and I’m not sure how to interpret it. It seems like, someone who feels that they hold an opinion but can’t really say why they do, can’t point to some principle upon which the opinion rests, nor articulate any deeply held beliefs that would direct their thinking to come to such and such a conclusion- that person (and I am not directing this at any particular individual), that hypothetical person seems like a dumbass. Am I totally misunderstanding what is being said here?

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      58 months ago

      Yeah thanks man. I don’t really expect to convince anybody here who is already been programed into a republican aparatchik. I am mostly posting for anyone reading this stuff who may be swayed by dumb arguments but can be pulled back from the brink by reason.

      I’m also using these posts as a way of clarifying and organizing my own thoughts. What do I think about things? Why do I think this or that? It can be useful to have somethi g to react to, and examine my own reactions.

      • PizzaMan
        link
        fedilink
        3
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        Seconded

        It was the exact same for me back when I argued about religion. But, a decent portion of it is also just for entertainment.

        Right now my girlfriend is in the ER with me, and I don’t have much else to do. Arguing on here passes the time rather quickly.

          • PizzaMan
            link
            fedilink
            2
            edit-2
            7 months ago

            She has a number of chronic illnesses. All in all its a pretty normal day as unfortunate as that is. She will be ok, but it’s still spooky.

            She is on medicaid. So when the conservatives around here say stupid shit like “i don’T wANt To pAy FOr SOmEbody ELse’s CARE. they sHoULD Get a JOb AnD pull ThEMSeLves UP By tHeIr BOoTSTrApS” it hits closer to home. They effectively want my girlfriend dead.

            Screaming my head off around here about it is slightly better than screaming into the void over their attempts to kill social services.