• @Rapidcreek
    link
    -4310 months ago

    There is no logic to a ceasefire without hostage release.

    Sorry Xi is disappointed

    • @mmcintyre
      link
      2710 months ago

      There is no logic to bombing, starving, shooting a population that doesn’t even have hostages.

      Sorry you enjoy murdering children vicariously

      • @theletterd
        link
        -310 months ago

        The problem is hostages are being held amongst and below the people. The tunnels are near hospitals, underneath the UNWRA building etc. It, by design, makes collateral damage impossible.

        Israel could level Gaza in a heartbeat if it wanted. It would look much different than telling them what’s about to happen, in advance and to relocate. I’m not saying it’s right or clean but it’s not egregious either.

      • @Rapidcreek
        link
        -1510 months ago

        So just because there is no logic for a ceasefire not to address hostages, therefore whoever points that out must be sympathetic to killing? Sorry, that makes no sense

        • @mmcintyre
          link
          1710 months ago

          You say it makes no sense to stop murdering Palestinian children unless Hamas releases hostages. Like, shooting children is a no-brainer.

          What makes you or Netanyahu any better than Hamas?

          Literally nothing.

          • @Rapidcreek
            link
            -1410 months ago

            No, I said there was no logic to calling for a ceasefire without addressing hostages.

            • @Eldritch
              link
              English
              1010 months ago

              It makes lots of sense. With a ceasefire Israel will stop shooting and blowing up their own hostages to be rescued.

              • @Rapidcreek
                link
                -1210 months ago

                That is not logical, that is your own fantasy.

                  • @Rapidcreek
                    link
                    -1010 months ago

                    At least I knew the word zionist before October 7th and know what it means. It’s not really a pejorative.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      -510 months ago

      It’s wild this is downvoted so much. Hamas isn’t going to ceasefire so if they’re not going to release the hostages then Israel doing a solo ceasefire is just saying you want more Israelis killed because that’s exactly what will happen if Hamas is able to get back on their feet. They continue to say as much.

      • @mmcintyre
        link
        710 months ago

        Israel isn’t killing Hamas. They are killing Palestinians. Thousands of children. And starving those still breathing. But apparently wanting more Gazans (and others in Gaza) killed is a totally cool and normal thing, and really… how gauche of me to mention it!

        Maybe Netanyahu shouldn’t have helped stand Hamas up in the first place if them being on their feet is such a problem.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          -210 months ago

          Ya, according to Hamas there hasn’t been a single fighter killed and you’re parroting that. FFS.

          Maybe Hamas should release the hostages and lay down their arms? That’s what is going to end this, nothing less and that’s been clear for months.

          Why won’t Hamas accept any of the deals Egypt has attempted to broker? They’ve been backed by multiple involved countries and Israel.

          Can’t have a one sided ceasefire, that’s not how that works.