The House Select Committee on the Chinese Communist Party sent a letter on Saturday to SpaceX and Tesla CEO Elon Musk demanding that U.S. troops stationed in Taiwan get access to SpaceX’s Starshield, a satellite communication network designed specifically for the military.

The letter, obtained by CNBC and first reported by Forbes, claimed that by not making Starshield available to U.S. military forces in Taiwan, SpaceX could violate its Pentagon contract, which requires “global access” to Starshield technology.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    19 months ago

    I’d love to better understand your position. it seems like you think that Starlink is aware of who is using a terminal. how can Starlink differentiate between a Ukrainian and Russian user in the same general area? should Starlink randomly turn off user terminals it suspects? what if it accidentally turns off a Ukrainian one? billing is obv not a good indicator

    I want to understand your thoughts a little more clearly on this

    • Flying Squid
      link
      39 months ago

      The area is Russian-occupied. Just turn off Starlink to that area. It’s not hard.

      Yes, that sucks for anyone stuck there. But this is war. You don’t let the Russians have an advantage.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        19 months ago

        I don’t think that’s where the problem I’m raising is. Think about an active confrontation area where both sides have Starlink. How do you tell which to turn off in this case? Ideally Ukraine would be using starshield and then Starlink can be turned off entirely

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            19 months ago

            that doesn’t seem to support your assertion. blocking terminals in a specific geographic location (crimea) doesn’t explain how to tell apart two sides using terminals in the same geographic area

            • Flying Squid
              link
              19 months ago

              Blocking terminals in the same geographic location- such as Russian-controlled territory? Something he isn’t doing?

              • @[email protected]
                link
                fedilink
                English
                19 months ago

                On an active battlefront these territories aren’t strictly defined or are changing quickly. With that methodology if Ukrainian advanced too quickly into what was previously Russian territory, bam - Starlink stops working. That seems undesirable

                • Flying Squid
                  link
                  09 months ago

                  Sorry… you’re saying that SpaceX can’t just turn access on and off whenever they feel like it? Like my ISP can if I don’t pay my bill?

                  Coordinating with the Ukrainian military would be enough to tell them what to turn on and off.

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    19 months ago

                    Starlink terminals in Ukraine didn’t come from one source. some have been donated by orgs in the US and other countries, some the government, some SpaceX themselves. Ukraine almost certainly doesn’t have full knowledge of all the Starlink terminals it possesses. This isn’t an ideal environment