• @Anti_Iridium
    link
    2
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    My Lai was not an ethnic cleansing campaign. It was not directed by the White House or the Pentagon. It was a massacre that had an attempted cover up.

    Is it really that hard to understand that something can be illegal, unethical, and immoral, and not be ethnic cleansing?

    British colonialist policies during WW2

    ’m just going to go ahead and assume it’s also a complete mystery to you why the vaunted US military failed so abysmally in Afghanistan, eh?

    This discussion is on vietnam, but cool.

    • @masquenox
      link
      -210 months ago

      My Lai was not an ethnic cleansing

      Oh… you didn’t get this the first time around. Here… let me help you along and repost it for you because you sure look like this is going to take you a lot of effort to get.

      Ooooh… you completely got me there. The millions dead in the Congo thanks to Belgium exploitation? Perfectly okay because it wasn’t a clear-cut case of “ethnic cleansing.” The millions starved to death in Bengal due to British colonialist policies during WW2? Perfectly fine because it wasn’t a clear-cut case of “ethnic cleansing.”

      Also, why bring up My Lai? There was nothing unique about My Lai - except for the fact that it ended up being reported in the US media because one chopper crew decided to grow a backbone and put a stop to it (for once). For the US military in Vietnam, My Lai was Tuesday.

      This discussion is on vietnam

      So do tell… how does a military end up being completely broken by a (supposedly) “inferior” enemy without actually having lost any decisive battles?

      I’d hate to think what would have actually happened if the US had lost a clear-cut battle in Vietnam - the entire US may just have imploded in on itself due to shock.

      • @Anti_Iridium
        link
        210 months ago

        I could have worded that better, my apologies there. The fact that someone stopped it, I think really is a difference.

        I never once said anything about the Vietcong being inferior.

        I’m done here, but I do suggest you go and do some more reading. Maybe watch Ken Burns Vietnam documentary to get started with.

        • @masquenox
          link
          -210 months ago

          I never once said anything about the Vietcong being inferior.

          This is not about what you said or didn’t say. The US empire is a fundamentally white supremacist empire - no different than the fundamentally white supremacist empires that gave birth to it - and therefore views anyone it wishes to subjugate, exploit and/or exterminate as “inferior.”

          but I do suggest you go and do some more reading.

          You first.