• @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    37
    edit-2
    7 months ago

    The source material is what keeps it from just being another generic fantasy setting with stereotypical characters, which is what the writers were turning The Witcher into in the very first season, and I heard it got worse from there but stopped watching.

    Great adaptations keep the important bits. Cavill trying to keep the important bits was the only reason the show wasn’t worse. The writers and producers were the ones who signed on for a Witcher project and tried to turn it into their own.

    • @SchmidtGenetics
      link
      English
      -35
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      Cavill reportedly badgered his agent to let him meet with The Witcher showrunner Lauren Schmidt-Hissrich as she recalls him being “really annoying” with his insistence on playing the lead role in the series that (at the time) she hadn’t even begun writing yet

      Yeah, no the show had no intentions of telling the same story from the start.

      Cavill messed everything up before even starting, this is entirely on him for pushing his way into a show and demanding what he wanted instead of what everyone else was doing.

        • @SchmidtGenetics
          link
          English
          -18
          edit-2
          7 months ago

          Why make multiple video games that have nothing to do with the source material as well? Very few adaptations are 100% faithful to the source material, lots tell alternate ideas, it’s hilarious that people think this one should be the outlier. The other media in this universe already has nothing to do with the books already lmfao.

          It’s called telling additional stories or fleshing out other stories.

          The Witcher could be a vast universe with multiple stories to tell, why tell the same one multiple times?

          • @[email protected]
            link
            fedilink
            English
            97 months ago

            There is a difference between telling different stories with the same settings and characters and changing the setting and characters enough that it loses the things that make the setting and characters unique.

            The Lord of the Rings movies were a great adaptation even though the deviated from the source material to fit the mew medium. The Dark Tower was a terrible adaptation, and felt like some other movie pretending to be the Dark Tower.

          • @RampantParanoia2365
            cake
            link
            English
            57 months ago

            Are you serious? The games are basically unofficial sequels to the books. They absolutely have something to do with them lol wtaf.

            • @SchmidtGenetics
              link
              English
              -127 months ago

              The games are basically unofficial sequels to the books. They absolutely have something to do with them lol wtaf.

              So are they faithful to the material, or are they a separate story like the show was?

              The games aren’t the books, the show wasn’t either, and people are mad about that, lmfao.

              • @RampantParanoia2365
                cake
                link
                English
                27 months ago

                They’re continuations of the story. They take the established lore and expand on them, just like an additional book would.

                • @SchmidtGenetics
                  link
                  English
                  -7
                  edit-2
                  7 months ago

                  Huh, just like what the show was doing…. What’s your point here again?

                  That one media can tell a different story than the books, but another can’t? Thats just asinine lmfao.

                  • @[email protected]
                    link
                    fedilink
                    English
                    -17 months ago

                    You can’t tell the difference between an adaptation and a sequel? The show was not a “different story”, it was a poorly-made adaptation that they didn’t want to make. They wanted Game of Thrones using an unrelated existing IP. If they really wanted a different story entirely, they should have avoided using the characters and events from the books.