Tildes is just too small. The obvious explanation for growth is all of the Fledditors (Rexit? I like Lemmygrants, but that really only covers people who came to Lemmy) looking for an alternative. People wanted a drop-in replacement for what they already had. Tildes didn’t even have enough of a seed in their biggest subs, let alone their (very few) niche groups. Same for Raddle, Squabbles, etc. The only subs that made a significant migration to those are the ones that packed up, locked the doors, and left a forwarding address to anyone left - Similar to what r/piracy did, except that went to Lemmy (complete with instructions to ignore the federation questions)
As for Kbin, I think the bigger factor is coverage. As soon as anyone started mentioning people leaving for greener pastures, Lemmy was always the first thing mentioned. Kbin was always a second-place alternative, along with a few others. Since Kbin has the same confusion about federation as Lemmy, it didn’t pick up a lot of people that bailed on the first choice.
Not that it matters much anymore, since Kbin is well-federated with Lemmy
Tildes also doesn’t allow memes and only accepts “quality content”, meaning they can delete your comments and threads if someone (idk who) thinks they aren’t good enough. This will cause everyone on tildes to sound like the same person.
Tildes is just too small. The obvious explanation for growth is all of the Fledditors (Rexit? I like Lemmygrants, but that really only covers people who came to Lemmy) looking for an alternative. People wanted a drop-in replacement for what they already had. Tildes didn’t even have enough of a seed in their biggest subs, let alone their (very few) niche groups. Same for Raddle, Squabbles, etc. The only subs that made a significant migration to those are the ones that packed up, locked the doors, and left a forwarding address to anyone left - Similar to what r/piracy did, except that went to Lemmy (complete with instructions to ignore the federation questions)
As for Kbin, I think the bigger factor is coverage. As soon as anyone started mentioning people leaving for greener pastures, Lemmy was always the first thing mentioned. Kbin was always a second-place alternative, along with a few others. Since Kbin has the same confusion about federation as Lemmy, it didn’t pick up a lot of people that bailed on the first choice.
Not that it matters much anymore, since Kbin is well-federated with Lemmy
Tildes also doesn’t allow memes and only accepts “quality content”, meaning they can delete your comments and threads if someone (idk who) thinks they aren’t good enough. This will cause everyone on tildes to sound like the same person.
“This will cause everyone on tildes to sound like the same person.”
Thats exactly my feeling on Tildes. And that person is too boring.
Thank you for the explanation. :) that does gives a clearer picture.
So it seems that lemmy just happens to be the most ready when the mass migration happened.
I like “fledditors”, but “reddfugees” is also good.
beeners f/ kbin
im a beener, ur a beener. we’re all beeners.
I personally wouldn’t have gone with something that sounds so similar to a common ethnic slur, y’know?
We are united in the fediverse 💪