Whether you’re really passionate about RPC, MQTT, Matrix or wayland, tell us more about the protocols or open standards you have strong opinions on!

  • @Mango
    link
    17 months ago

    I read the first two and kinda gave up my dude. Here’s my deal. I get that it’s bad under the hood. What else can I use that lets me and a friend pretend we just have folders in each other’s computers with just a port forward, IP, and a password?

    • Natanael
      link
      fedilink
      17 months ago

      That’s not even the type of setup you should use. Use a VPN of the type designed for games and IoT stuff, like ZeroTier, n2n, and more. Then you set up a local file share using something like Samba, only accessible by the people who can connect to your local network via the VPN.

      The public facing VPN code will be MUCH more hardened against attack than your typical sharing tool with port forwarding.

      • @Mango
        link
        17 months ago

        I’m less worried about attack than barriers to sharing.

        • Natanael
          link
          fedilink
          17 months ago

          If you set up port forwarding for file shares you must keep setting it up again for every new service.

          If you set up a VPN once then you’re simply done. Every new service you set up is available directly.

          • @Mango
            link
            17 months ago

            No middleman pls.

            • Natanael
              link
              fedilink
              17 months ago

              ZeroTier can be a fully self hosted VPN. You set up a server locally, port forward only the VPN service, and then everything else you run is accessible through it for the people you give access to.

              • @Mango
                link
                07 months ago

                Who knows what else it does with that secret code.

                • Natanael
                  link
                  fedilink
                  27 months ago

                  They’re are multiple open source options like n2n

        • BaldProphet
          link
          fedilink
          07 months ago

          ZeroTier is pretty easy to set up, but at the point where you’re worrying about “barriers to sharing” you should probably using a cloud service anyway.

          • @Mango
            link
            17 months ago

            Ahhh but that’s the thing. A middleman being necessary is very against my values. I don’t want there being someone else or there limiting or telling me no. I’m not letting someone else’s DMCA compliance tell me what I can have. I’m also not really interested in non FLOSS.

            • Badabinski
              link
              fedilink
              1
              edit-2
              7 months ago

              You should be able to just use ssh/sftp. There are lots of great clients, and you can absolutely still use usernames and passwords, no public/private key stuff required. You can even use ssh and scp right from powershell on Windows boxen if you’re so inclined. There’s winscp, and if you want filesystem mounting, there’s this: https://github.com/winfsp/sshfs-win
              For macos and Linux, the options are far more plentiful.

              Edit: there’s also file pizza, which is a file transfer thingy with no middle man that’s open source, although it’s not copyleft AFAICT: https://github.com/kern/filepizza
              and similar tools. Not really what you’re after, I just think it’s neat.

              • @Mango
                link
                17 months ago

                It’s probably been 15 years since I used ssh. I’m gonna guess there’s better UI for it now, or at least a UI at all.

                • Badabinski
                  link
                  fedilink
                  1
                  edit-2
                  7 months ago

                  There are definitely a lot of good options out there. What are you using right now for regular old FTP? The odds are actually pretty good that it already supports SFTP. A lot of file management applications do both and lump them together, even though they’re completely different protocols (sftp is from the late nineties).

                  If it doesn’t, then I don’t know what OS you’re using, so I’ll just recommend options for the big 3. For Windows, there’s WinSCP. For MacOS there’s Cyberduck. Most file managers on Linux distros let you just type sftp://me@wherever in the navigation bar, meaning you get a totally seamless experience with the rest of your FS.

                  EDIT: or, you can use sshfs-win on Windows and have your remote filesystem show up as a regular ol’ drive, just like SMB. MacOS and Linux have sshfs, and I know there are GUIs wrapping sshfs on those platforms. I personally use sshfs at home and it’s great (although no GUI wrapper, I’m a weirdo who doesn’t use a graphical file manager at all).

                  • @Mango
                    link
                    17 months ago

                    Oh I don’t have a computer right now. I got reamed by the law over a lie from a road rager and lost everything.