Among candidates for U.S. sanctions, Israel’s Prison Service should be next on the list. This is apparently the realm where all the sadistic instincts of the minister of national security, Itamar Ben-Gvir, find their outlet.
On October 26, large forces of the Prison Service’s Keter unit, a tactical intervention unit, accompanied by dogs, one of them unleashed, stormed into the prison. The wardens and the dogs went on a rampage, attacking the inmates whose screams left the whole prison in a state of terror, Abu Halil recalls. The walls were soon covered with inmates’ blood. “You are Hamas, you are ISIS, you raped, murdered, abducted and now your time has come,” said one warden to the prisoners. The blows that followed were brutal, the inmates were shackled.
The beatings became a daily affair. Occasionally the guards demanded of prisoners that they kiss an Israeli flag and declaim, “Am Yisrael Chai!” – “The People of Israel live.” They were also ordered to curse the prophet Mohammed. The usual call to prayer in the cells was prohibited. The prisoners were afraid to utter any word starting with the sound “h” lest the guards suspect they had said “Hamas.”
On October 29, the inmates of Abu Halil’s cell requested a squeegee to wash the floor. The response to that was to send the terrifying Keter unit into their cell. “Now you will be like dogs,” the guards ordered. The prisoners’ hands were cuffed behind their back. Even before they were shackled, they were ordered to move only with their upper body bent over. They were led to the kitchen, where they were stripped and forced to lie one on top of the other, a pile of 10 naked prisoners. Abu Halil was the last. There, they were beaten with clubs and spat on.
A guard then started to stuff carrots into the anus of Abu Halil and other prisoners. Sitting at home now, reciting his story, Abu Halil lowers his gaze and the flow of words slows down. He’s embarrassed to talk about this. Afterward, he continues, dogs hunched over them and attacked them. They were then allowed to put on their underwear before being led back to their cell, where they found their clothes thrown into a heap.
Basically, other things roughly equal, you’re on the wrong side if your side has cowardice more normalized - as in, for example, abusing others while being safe yourself.
ISIS, Hamas etc are already better because those doing the abuse are usually also those who consciously risk their lives.
The criterion is empirical and emotional, but I can’t think of a single case in any war or conflict which would disprove this.
Now, for Israelis (I know being a cowardly bully is only human) this moral distinction doesn’t seem obvious. Actually fighting somebody equal to them is something unthinkable, yet they are proud of their military.
I mean, how can one be proud of the military that squeals for Western help every time an adversary can hurt it (not even defeat it, just the thought that they can be hurt back in something called a war is outrageous for them).
Yeah I hate ISIS with the same passion as israel. But it’s always hilarious to see people make fun of fighters actually risking their lives on the ground to “come out in the open and stop fighting like cowards” against a drone flying 10 miles high in the sky controlled remotely from half the world away by a dude on an airbase in Texas.