The other guy is probably being a bit over the top, but your initial comment was kinda anti-Semitic, no?
Like, if I was reading a comment thread about black people and responded, “but is it as funny as eating fried chicken and watermelon,” I don’t think someone would be out of line saying, “are you asserting that all black people just eat fried chicken and watermelon?”
And then saying the thread isn’t about them isn’t exactly absolving the initial comment is it? The comment would still be racist, no?
Idk man, that guy got disproportionately hot about it I think, but your initial comment was a bit rough too, right?
Are you making the extremely bigoted assumption that just because I’m Jewish I’m in favor of circumcision?
?
I made a comment, on a thread.
The other guy is probably being a bit over the top, but your initial comment was kinda anti-Semitic, no?
Like, if I was reading a comment thread about black people and responded, “but is it as funny as eating fried chicken and watermelon,” I don’t think someone would be out of line saying, “are you asserting that all black people just eat fried chicken and watermelon?”
And then saying the thread isn’t about them isn’t exactly absolving the initial comment is it? The comment would still be racist, no?
Idk man, that guy got disproportionately hot about it I think, but your initial comment was a bit rough too, right?
A thread where, at the top, I said I was Jewish.
So, I reiterate- are you making the assumption that Jews are all in favor of circumcision?
It’s really not about you, as keen as you are for it to be so.
I ask you again: are you making the assumption that Jews are all in favor of circumcision?
Jews. Not just me.
Why are you harassing me ?
I don’t think asking you to clarify is harassment, but I guess you don’t want to clarify, and I think I know why, so I won’t continue the discussion.