Trump’s defense team has moved for a mistrial over Stormy Daniels’ testimony

“We move for a mistrial based on the testimony this morning,” defense attorney Todd Blanche said following the lunch break.

“The guardrails by this witness answering questions by the government were just thrown to the side,” Blanche said.

“There is no remedy that we can fashion … to unring this bell,” Blanche said about the impact of Daniels’ testimony.

Blanche argued the prosecutors wanted to embarrass Trump and inflame the jury and was far afield from a case about falsification of business records.

“She talked about a consensual encounter with President Trump that she was trying to sell,” Blanche said. “We heard a completely different story.”

Blanche argued that the testimony regarding condoms, being “blacked out” and and the “power dynamic” prejudiced the jury.

“This has nothing to do with the reason why we’re here,” Blanche said. “How can you un-ring a bell?”

The prosecution pushed back.

“Her account completes the narrative that precipitated the falsification of business records,” Hoffinger said. “It is precisely what the defendant did not want to become public.”

  • Avid Amoeba
    link
    fedilink
    747 months ago

    I have a feeling he doesn’t have the best lawyers representing him.

    • @DeepThought42
      link
      English
      81
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      “I was surprised that there were not more objections,” from the defense team he added. “At one point, the court … objected, because there was no objection coming from the defense.”

      Either they are bad lawyers or they were strategically withholding their objections in order to file the mistrial motion. I fully expect this to be brought up again in an appeal, assuming Trump loses the case.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        29
        edit-2
        7 months ago

        Convicted defendents in New York stay in prison during the appeal process. But of course we wont see that fucking happen because money reasons.

      • Echo Dot
        link
        fedilink
        77 months ago

        Can they file for a miss trail on the grounds that they themselves didn’t do the thing that’s expected of them in the time it was expected for them to do it.

        Surely a lawyer can’t deliberately do a bad job, and then file for a mistrial.

        • @DeepThought42
          link
          English
          17 months ago

          As far as I’m aware nothing will stop them from trying to do that. It’s up to the judge (or judges if it goes to an appeal) to decide whether their argument makes sense. While I’d hope that a competent judge will see their shenanigans for what it is, I have no doubt that someone has made that strategy work at some point.

          To be clear, I’m not a lawyer, so naturally don’t take my word for it.

      • @cybersandwich
        link
        67 months ago

        That’s exactly what they were aiming for. It was their hail Mary because they know they don’t have an actual defense

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      367 months ago

      Yes, but also in their defense they don’t have the best client. It’s like they deserve each other.

    • @slickgoat
      link
      327 months ago

      I’ve been following this trial very closely. Trump is the problem. He demands that his lawyers challenge everything very aggressively. He is enraged if his counsel accepts even trivial facts that make no difference either way. The bigger question is why they put up with his tantrums.

      Money, probably…

      • @baldingpudenda
        link
        107 months ago

        He’s not gonna pay. He’ll say he lost so why pay. He’s got almost 500 million on bond for business fraud, 5 million for rape of Ms. Carroll, I think I’m missing another big one, and he’s freaking out at donors for not giving enough.

        He’s got no field offices set up and only really doing campaign rallies, if you don’t count the desperate emails begging for donations. The only thing keeping his “campaign” going right now is the cult.

        • Jaysyn
          link
          fedilink
          47 months ago

          He’s been having to pay up front since he lost White House counsel.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          27 months ago

          Don’t you think his lawyers insisted on a large retainer up front? They all know his finances.

          • @baru
            link
            17 months ago

            There have been loads of people who knew he doesn’t pay and still thought they’d be the exception.

            • Jaysyn
              link
              fedilink
              27 months ago

              He’s literally having to pay up front. Kise got a $5M retainer.

    • Flying Squid
      link
      317 months ago

      If he paid lawyers, he might get good ones.

    • @cheese_greater
      link
      19
      edit-2
      7 months ago

      Blanche was actually a pretty respected prosecutor turned defense attorney, its surprising he took the case unless he wanted to get out of law and this was his swansong before transitioning to some sweet talkinghead gig or other well-paid right-wing political operative role

    • @captainlezbian
      link
      77 months ago

      Yeah historically they like being paid and really aren’t jumping at the chance to do polarizing work for free

    • Jaysyn
      link
      fedilink
      77 months ago

      Blanche used to be a respected lawyer. I hope the payday was enough to pay for the reputational damage he’s taking.