• @perviouslyiner
    link
    256 months ago

    If someone was going to jail for having those documents, making them available to the public might not be the best demonstration of why they needed to be kept secret.

    • Hildegarde
      link
      -226 months ago

      On the contrary, releasing the documents would demonstrate exactly why the documents were kept secret. However, doing so would not retroactively legalize mishandling the documents when they were classified.

      • @barsquid
        link
        46 months ago

        Oh, declassify the documents in question in the case so it can proceed?

        It won’t help, though. This Judge is colluding with the defense. There will just be another excuse. Everything would be declassified for no reason.

        IDK I guess it really doesn’t matter if they’re declassified now since Donald already sold them to foreign adversaries.

        • Hildegarde
          link
          -76 months ago

          Trump is only being charged with mishandling the documents. If he sold them, that is a much more serious crime and they would have charged him for that instead of just mishandling.

          If the documents really were sold there wouldn’t be a good reason to keep them classified. The worst has already happened. The only thing keeping the documents classified does in that case is hamper the prosecution from pursuing the case.

            • Hildegarde
              link
              -26 months ago

              Correlation ≠ causation.

                • Hildegarde
                  link
                  -1
                  edit-2
                  6 months ago

                  If the accusations were credible they would be in a court rather than on twitter. Countries are constantly trying to uncover the spies of other countries. If russia or any other country is capturing more spies that itself is not evidence of a breach, it could be caused by many other factors.

                  It is possible to evaluate the credibility of claims even when those claims are against someone we all hate.

          • @baru
            link
            16 months ago

            If the documents really were sold there wouldn’t be a good reason to keep them classified. The worst has already happened. The only thing keeping the documents classified does in that case is hamper the prosecution from pursuing the case.

            How would declassifying not help? How would declassifying not cause the case to be impacted negatively because the case is about classified documents?

            • Hildegarde
              link
              16 months ago

              Juries make decisions on the facts of the case when the crime occurs. Declassifying the documents now does not change the facts of the case as the documents were classified when the crime occurred.

              Keeping the documents classified is an issue because they are evidence, and juries can’t do their job if they are not allowed to see the evidence.

              Declassifying documents is a process with a known timeframe. The jury issue isn’t.