• @blazeknave
    link
    67 months ago

    Isn’t effect a noun, affect a verb? Am I supposed to discern which in other ways?

    • @ClockworkOtter
      link
      127 months ago

      To “affect” a change would be to alter the change itself, for example if the university had already been reviewing its portfolio then the protesters might be affecting the change by making it happen more quickly.

      To “effect” a change would be to cause the change in the first place.

    • prole
      link
      fedilink
      English
      37 months ago

      This is one of the few oddities of the English language that I struggle with constantly. It seems like, as a native speaker, most of the other ones just “feel” or “sound” right, but I haven’t been able to nail that down with effect/affect for some reason

      • Jojo, Lady of the West
        link
        fedilink
        27 months ago

        The trouble is that both words have a verb sense and a noun sense.

        The noun sense of affect is something like “mood” or “emotion” and isn’t used often, while the noun sense of effect is “thing that happened (because of some cause)” and is a rather common word.

        The verb sense of affect is “to cause something to happen (to something)” and is a pretty common word, while the verb sense of effect is more like “to make something be true” as in “effecting change” above.

        The mnemonic I use is from dungeons and dragons, some spells are “mind-affecting effects” meaning they change minds and they’re caused by the spell being cast.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          47 months ago

          If I use my Persuasion skill to help someone think their way through a problem, is that a “mind-effecting affect”?

          • Jojo, Lady of the West
            link
            fedilink
            17 months ago

            I don’t know that I’d say persuasion skills are an affect, but if your mood gives people ideas, that’d work.

    • @Crackhappy
      link
      English
      17 months ago

      I hope to effect a change in your perspective.

    • @Burn_The_Right
      link
      17 months ago

      “Effect” can also be used as a verb, as used above.

      • @jaybone
        link
        57 months ago

        Both can be both nouns and verbs. This to me is the most annoying English oddity of all.