• Orbituary
    link
    English
    3411 months ago

    This silly article doesn’t even discuss the fact that Dr Kwok was a made up person and the entire premise of MSG being bad for you was a staged prank to get an article published without peer review.

    Give this a listen.

    https://www.thisamericanlife.org/668/transcript

  • Drusas
    link
    fedilink
    3211 months ago

    Salt being unhealthy is, for the majority of people, a myth in much the same way that MSG being unhealthy is a myth.

    Studies show that having too little salt in your diet is more likely to cause cardiac events than having the recommended or slightly to moderately above the daily recommended amount is. Having an extremely high sodium intake is similarly found to have poor cardiac implications, but that is at very high levels which most people do not hit. There is a subset of the population who are known as being “salt-sensitive” who need to limit their sodium intake in order to keep blood pressure at a healthy level, but they are the minority. Similarly, there is a subset of the population that needs a higher level of sodium intake due to their own health conditions (such as POTS or cystic fibrosis).

    I don’t have those studies immediately on hand, but I tend to read them when they come up because I have both POTS and cystic fibrosis so this myth becomes very tiresome. The below site sources.

    https://immieats.com/the-sodium-myth-debunked-why-salt-is-not-the-enemy/

    https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/its-time-to-end-the-war-on-salt/

    • @Snoozemumrik
      link
      English
      611 months ago

      The classic “the dose makes the poison” is pretty relevant

    • Chozo
      link
      fedilink
      1011 months ago

      I believe so, as OP’s post history shows more articles from the same author.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        English
        911 months ago

        That was my feeling as well. I was trying to give them the benefit of the doubt. They have not replied. I have no issue with self promotion as long as there is disclosure and it is not excessive.

        So, with that said, and with no reply, this fucking blog post in ‘health’ is a total steaming pile.

  • @blahsay
    link
    English
    -1511 months ago

    MSG gives me crazy migraines.

    Hope it doesn’t get put in too many things

    • @morph3ous
      link
      English
      3611 months ago

      My Mom says it does the same to her. Then she eats Dorito chips or uses a seasoning in it that has MSG and nothing happens. When I point that out she is still convinced that it gives her migraines and maybe those things just don’t have enough of it.

      🤷

      • Kid_Thunder
        link
        fedilink
        211 months ago

        Same with my wife and I put MSG in some stuff that I make and she never complains but trust me, I know when she gets headaches or migraines. Not that I did it on purpose. It came up when she saw me bring in 2 lbs. of it and I’m just thinking to myself that she apparently has no idea that I use it somewhat commonly.

        • @NoSpotOfGround
          link
          English
          5
          edit-2
          11 months ago

          FWIW, I get a seriously intense headache precisely 9 seconds after eating a large pinch of MSG (because it’s so tasty). It completely goes away 10 seconds later. I have no doubt it can cause headaches (in at least some people), and everyone denying it looks ridiculously sanctimonious to me.

          I bet there are some self-delusions about these headaches, but they’re not 100% fake. You’re being just as foolish denying them as the people who are 100% sure they’re all real. Reactions can differ from person to person.

    • @blahsay
      link
      English
      -111 months ago

      Wow crazy downvotes for being honest.

      And thanks for that one guy - you’re right: migraines are all in my head 🤪