This… this was a low-key life changer.
I made the recipe as it was originally done and it was pretty much the simplest, quickest thing I have ever made.
You need noodles (I used a simple pack of the “fresh” noodles from the supermarket, it took literally 2 minutes to cook), a block of decent Parmesan cheese that you will shred about a cup of (gotta go with a block that you shred yourself, the pre-shredded doesn’t work), and four tablespoons of butter. That’s it.
You boil the noodles per the package (it was 2 minutes for the ones I used), then pull them from the water and put them wet in a large bowl with the butter. Add a small amount of the water you boiled the noodles in (like 1/3rd cup or so) and then slowly add in the cheese, mixing it as you go. That’s it. You can add more pasta water if you want it saucier, but mix it until the cheese and butter melts into a sauce and you are good to go.
With the fresh noodles, it maybe takes 5 or 6 minutes and was a very tasty and filling meal. Totally worth it.
The butter and Parmesan version doesn’t feel as heavy as the cream version, in my opinion.
It’s been in my Rolodex for a while!
I have a good heavy cream version that I like to make from scratch and it is really good, but this was so simple and tasty that it is going to be something that I keep on tap for an easy night where I still want something amazing.
Oh this sounds really good! Alfredo sauces are usually a no go for me (I’m lactose intolerant and vegetarian) but Parmesan doesn’t contain too much lactose so this seems perfect.
Seems like the addition of something like peas or asparagus would be extra delicious as well!
Depending how strictly you are vegetarian, many parmesan cheeses (quite a few other cheeses too) use animal rennet. It is something i tend to overlook in my vegetarian diet.
Is this a cheeky way of getting Tasting History with Max Miller content spread around? ‘Cause I’m here for it!
I was going to make a similar comment 😁 Love that channel
For some reason as I’ve gotten older I’ve lost the taste for alfredo sauce. I loved it when I was a kid but now I just much prefer a tomato based sauce. I’m not sure why as I love creamy sauces as well as parmesan. Maybe I need to try making it myself and see.
This version is a good bit different than the cream versions that you generally find. Pretty much just butter, cheese and pasta water.
Thanks, I’ll have to give yours a go next time I make pasta.
Add some rough chopped Italian (the big leaf kind) for an added kick. Also, even if you leave the parsley out, go hard with the black pepper.
TIL from a Matteo Lane video that fettuccine Alfredo is an American recipe.
Not the version that I am talking about here. This particular version was invented in Rome and was quite famous in its time.
the pre-shredded doesn’t work
Why not?
Pre-shredded cheese never melts as well because they spray a coating on them to keep them from sticking together in the package.
I think there is something that is generally added to prevent it from sticking together if I remember correctly. You could certainly try it, but grating a cup of parm is not too difficult and it tasty.
Interesting. I buy the “good” pre-shredded parm from the fancy cheese section and it melts pretty well in my depression mac and cheese. I wonder if I just got lucky with the brand they sell where I shop.
The worst that happens is that it doesn’t form an emulsion with the butter and the water. I say give it a try and see how it turns out. Just remember to report back here so we can all learn from your experiment!
Anti-clumping agents are generally put in pre-shredded cheeses, but you can get bags of shredded “melting cheeses” that don’t have them though. In my experience that’s only a supermercado kinda thing. That said your “good” pre-shredded could also be in that category.
All pre-shredded has cellulose powder as an anti-clumping agent. Even the “good” pre-shredded.
Now, cellulose powder won’t keep things from melting, but it will make it harder to get a creamy sauce without a grainy texture.
As a note, if you want to help things along, add a slice of American cheese. The sodium citrate that makes the cheese smooth and pliable will keep your sauce from breaking. It also adds some creamy texture.
Pre shredded cheese is covered in starch or something similar to prevent clumping but also makes it harder to melt into a sauce. It’s still doable but the end texture will probably end up being lumpy
Pre-shredded cheese has preservatives in it that prevent it from melting properly
Sounds like someone’s been watching Tasting History videos…
Haven’t really seen anything other than the Alfredo one actually. That is what started me looking into this recipe.
Are there any you recommend I watch and try out next? I like learning new ways to make awesome food.
I have been wanting to try this way! I’ve always done the recipes calling for flour cream and milk. Happy to hear yours turned out delicious. Gives me a renewed excitement to try. I may do homemade noodles because I’m not sure I have great noodle options around me.
I love alfredo, but I’ve never made it traditionally like you did. I’ll give it a shot for my next date night!
