Though the finding may seem intuitive, it contradicts the notion that European Jews mostly descend from people who left Israel and the Middle East around 2,000 years ago. Instead, a substantial proportion of the population originates from local Europeans who converted to Judaism, said study co-author Martin Richards, an archaeogeneticist at the University of Huddersfield in England.
Yeah, I thought this was like, what defined Ashkenazi Jews. Maybe it’s surprising to folks in the middle east and North Africa?
Yet they claim to be indigenous and are returning home instead of the truth. That’s where the “surprise” part in the title comes from. I had many people argue with me that Ashkenazi are indigenous to Palestine and the descendants of people who left 2000 years ago. Worse many of them claim to be our (Arabs) cousins.
Maybe it’s surprising to folks in the middle east and North Africa?
Them turning bright red in the summer left no room for surprises. We always knew. It is NBC News and Western outlets that are surprised.
Lol
This not true, and the human genome hadn’t even been completed at the time. I’m anti Israel have been all my life. But this just isn’t true.
I don’t understand. this is a study from 2013, and the genome was mapped by 2003
Refutation without a counter source isn’t welcome here. Wasting people’s time is a troll tactic. It is another thing if you had a source that proves your claim, but you don’t.
The genome study is one evidence, another evidence is their susceptibility to melanoma unlike the indigenous Palestinians.
It’s not enough being anti-Israel if you still promote the foundational myths of Zionism. Ashkenazi Jews are not indigenous to Palestine or any part of the Middle East.
Not really surprising. It is the most obvious thing actually unless you are blinded by ideology.
It’s also an article from 2013…
Just agreeing that it’s a garbage post - sorry if that ellipsis was ambiguous.
And? Where’s the rule against posts from 2013?
Anyways I will edit the title and add it. But it is frustrating that this is even an issue!
Lol, what
At some level I get that a post from 2013 isn’t news but it is also a topic about an ongoing conflict and to this day I have to bring up this article and others to people who insist that Ashkenazi Jews are indigenous and cousins to the Arabs.
This is not a news community. So I would like to be able to post relevant articles even if they were from the 19th century.
But…?
An alternative source for those who think NBC News is making it up.