I remember

spoiler

a couple different things.

less clearly, i remember Hanks trying to kill himself, the branch breaking and then you seeing the broken tree until the scene fades to black into the next scene. but I suspect this scene was actually from another movie.

more clearly, i remember Tom hanks’ character suicide-testing a wooden dummy to test the carrying capacity of the branch that is on a short but tall-enough cliff, but the dummy is too heavy and the branch breaks.

Branch can’t break twice, so I’m clearly remembering something wrong, but I “know” that whatever I saw happened fairly early on in the movie and was not his description of attempted suicide near the end of the movie.

I remember a fairly lengthy (2-3 minutes) action scene of him physically testing the tree off a cliff.

other people swear that neither scene was in the movie and there’s only the description of his attempted suicide at the end.

there are unsubstantiated rumors that the scene was in the theatrical version(which is the version i saw) but not in home releases.

I haven’t seen the movie since I saw it in theaters when it came out.

What do you remember?

    • @[email protected]OP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      2
      edit-2
      4 months ago

      ooh nice good call. That’s a great movie.

      spoiler

      does dano make a wooden dummy in that movie?

      Is the tree on a cliff?

      I should watch that again.

      • @CitizenKong
        link
        English
        34 months ago

        Radcliffe plays the corpse, so no.

          • @CitizenKong
            link
            English
            14 months ago

            Still, Dano doesn’t create a wodden dummy before trying to kill himself. :)

              • @CitizenKong
                link
                English
                24 months ago

                It’s been a while longer since I saw it but at no point does he contemplate suicide that I can remember.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    54 months ago

    I’m 90% sure that he goes to the top of the mountain to get the rope that he used because he already used up all of the plant he needed and still came up short.

    They never show him doing it, they only show him pulling the wooden dummy up past the broken branch, then he tells his friend about it explicitly after being rescued.