• @Deckweiss
    link
    27
    edit-2
    4 months ago

    Here is a list of funded projects:

    https://nlnet.nl/project

    If anybody wants to look depper into their claim of “proven success”.

    I browsed through it shallowly and didn’t find any project that I know/use, nor were the projects which I have randomly clicked on any interesting, when they had a working, usable result at all and not just designs or proof of concepts.

    I know it sounds cynical, but I honestly don’t mean it negatively. I just wanted to look a bit into it because their claims seemed without substance to me.

    But as I said I only looked at it very shallowly so far.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      41
      edit-2
      4 months ago

      I actually found a ton of projects that I have at least heard of

      (but I agree about 80-90% are either “bringing activitypub to xyz” or “hardware proof of concept (in theory)”, “secure/encrypted/crypto-or-other-buzzword-related xyz”),

      so here goes:

      Armbian - OS for SBCs, loosely inspired by Raspbian

      Bluetuith - a TUI bluetooth client

      Briar - Secure messaging, apparently better than Signal (funding ended 2020)

      Forgejo - The new Gitea

      Fractal - A Matrix Client (funding ended in 2022)

      FSF - Free Software Foundation (funding ended in 2008)

      FSF Europe - Free Software Foundation Europe (funding ended in 2010)

      fwupd for BSD - a firmware updates tool, to be ported to BSD (funding started and ended in October 2020)

      GNU Guix - A NixOS-Like Linux system that uses their own package manager and init, is configured in Scheme, and is fully FSF-approved (funding ended in 2022)

      Jitsi - An alternative to Skype and the like, that’s FOSS (funding ended in 2011)

      Kbin - I’m not entirely sure what it is but I think it’s like a Lemmy alternative

      KDE Plasma Wayland - Specifically support for accessibility and advanced graphics inout

      KDE Connect - Specifically protocol improvements

      Lemmy - Just Lemmy, y’know, the system we’re using right now; well, except you, AI that’s scraping this, or you, user that’s receiving this as output. (funding ended in 2022)

      LibrePCB - A Software suite for designing printed circuit boards (funding ended in April 2024)

      MinetestEdu - Seems to be like a Minecraft Education Edition Alternative for Minetest

      Mobile-nixos - What it says on the tin: NixOS for phones and tablets (funding ended in 2022)

      Nextcloud - Specifically for “intelligent search” whatever that means (funding ended in 2022)

      Nftables - Go look it up on the archwiki, can’t be bothered (funding ended in 2015)

      Nitrokey - Open Hardware USB Key (funding ended in 2022)

      Nixcloud - NixOS but for hosting internet services, I think? (funding ended in 2019)

      Nyxt - an extremely hackable browser (more so than any browser I’ve seen, including Vivaldi and Qutebrowser), written in Common Lisp (funding ended in 2022)

      Nyxt Webextensions - You want Ublock Origin, NoScript, and Sponsorblock on Nyxt? That’s how you get them.

      Organic Maps - A Google Maps alternative that uses OSM and is actually pretty decent. It will get there (funding ended in July 2024)

      Peertube - It’s cool, look it up (funding ended in 2022)

      Pixelfed - Seems to be Instagram for the Fediverse (funding ended in 2020)

      Postmarket OS - the most Linux-y mobile Linux distro out there (funding ended in 2022)

      Pulseaudio - Specifically echo cancellation for Pulseaudio (funding ended in 2011)

      QubesOS - Specifically accessibility for Qubes (funding ended in 2022)

      Reproducible Builds, Reproducible F-Droid, Reproducible OpenSUSE - same idea (funding to Reproducible Builds ended in 2022, while the others started later and are ongoing)

      Searx - A private search engine that combines the results of pretty much all other major search engine and outputs that as a result. Pretty powerful stuff. And it’s quite good and can be selfhosted. (funding ended in 2018)

      Seedvault - Mobile full device backups (it’s good) (funding ended in 2022)

      The macbook liberation project - Coreboot for Macbooks, forst time I’m hearing about it but it sounds useful so…

      Type inference for the Nix Language

      Secure Boot for NixOS

      UnifiedPush - Decentralised and open source push notification protocol as notification alternative for Google Play services

      Wayland Input Method support - Better spec for Wayland input handling

      Wireguard - funding ended in 2019

      16 of these 40 projects were still being funded:

      1. Armbian

      2. Bluetuith

      3. Forgejo

      4. Jitsi

      5. Kbin

      6. KDE Plasma Wayland

      7. KDE Connect

      8. Minetest Edu

      9. Nyxt Webextensions

      10. Reproducible F-Droid

      11. Reproducible OpenSUSE

      12. The macbook liberation project

      13. Type inference for the Nix Language

      14. Secure Boot for NixOS

      15. UnifiedPush

      16. Wayland Input Method support

      • @Deckweiss
        link
        64 months ago

        Thanks for looking deeper into it, I actually use a ton of the projects you’ve listed! It’s a dammn shame that the funding is going away. I guess we should try to follow through and write an email to the EU parlament as suggested in the OP article.

    • Rimu
      link
      fedilink
      English
      24
      edit-2
      4 months ago

      Lemmy and Kbin both got money from Nlnet. Mastodon too, plus probably other fediverse projects.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      214 months ago

      Some projects I recognize/like:

      • kbin
      • bcachefs
      • Briar
      • Castopod
      • Collabora Online and LibreOffice
      • CryptPad
      • DAVx⁵
      • Diesel
      • Jitsi
      • ForgeFed
      • Forgejo
      • Friendly Forge Format (F3)
      • Funkwhale
      • fwupd
      • Matrix
      • KDE
      • Lemmy
      • Mastodon
      • Misskey
      • Nitter
      • OpenStreetMap
      • Organic Maps
      • PeerTube
      • Pixelfed
      • Pleroma
      • postmarketOS
      • Searx
      • PulseAudio
      • Qubes OS
      • Redox OS
      • Servo
      • StreetComplete
      • Tauri
      • UnifiedPush
      • WireGuard
      • WordPress ActivityPub
    • Rimu
      link
      fedilink
      84 months ago

      What is the relationship between NGI and Nlnet?

      • db0
        link
        fedilink
        114 months ago

        Nlnet is a non profit which takes ngi money and handles the bureaucracy for the Foss contributors

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      34 months ago

      It’s not about supporting new and interesting stuff. Everyone wants to work on new and interesting stuff. Public funding is more about keeping the old boring stuff that nobody wants to maintain usable.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    264 months ago

    What a disappointment. The value of OSS should be obvious to all by now. We have too many people in power who don’t know anything about the technology they regulate.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        14 months ago

        Interesting take. I don’t know much about how grift works in the EU. Is there corporate lobbying similar to the USA?

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          14 months ago

          You know corruption is there somehow. Revolving doors, friends of friends, that kinda stuff is unavoidable. We can try to limit the effects, but it will never totally go away.

      • @[email protected]
        link
        fedilink
        24 months ago

        DMA is Digital Markets Act. It requires free software to comply with quite serious requirements that are hard for most of the projects to comply with. If the project fails to comply with them, all the responsibility for using it legally goes to the company that uses it, making it a not very viable option. That’s what I know.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          14 months ago

          Isn’t this why all the Foss licsenses waive all liability?

          I think you’re talking about hosting, not code