Well, since Threads users can now see replies to their posts from Fediverse users AND they’re public, I think it’s as good a time as any to ask this again.
Have you blocked Threads?
This is for single users. If you’re an admin that has blocked it for your entire instance, it’s okay to answer as well, but I would like any users of those instances to also answer yes and for those that do not agree with that decision reply below with your thoughts, please!
Thanks!
PS. This is not a debate. I’m not looking for reasons why Threads should be blocked. Those types of replies will be completely ignored. We all know the pros and cons by now.
#Fedi #Fediverse #ActivityPub #Mastodon #Threads #Meta #SocialMedia #Poll #Polls
I dont think I can on Lemmy or I would. I’m down to block them individually as I see them tho.
@[email protected] thanks for you insight, friend.🙏
Unfortunately I didn’t think about platforms like Lemmy when creating this. I don’t know much about Lemmy.😬
I don’t even know how this post is viewed there since I didn’t mention a specific community.
Is there a federated feed like on Mastodon and other microblogging softwares?🤔
It looks like on here it was posted to [email protected]
I dont know much else. Something with the account or community addresses being tagged. But yes there is a feed. Its like reddit sort of.
@[email protected] ohh…that’s interesting…🤔
That’s an Mbin community so I wonder if they have something in the code to pull stuff based on hashtags.
Thanks for the quick response!😁
I haven’t seen any threads posts, but if one pollutes my feed then I will absolutely block it. Short form and vertical videos suck.
@[email protected] well…threads is a microblogging platform like Mastodon or X. While there could be videos like that there, it’s not the main feature of the platform like TikTok or Youtube Shorts.
How, as a single user, can I block threads?
@[email protected] tbh, I’m not sure how it works from Lemmy…😳
On Mastodon, you would have to see a users profile from threads and click the “…” Menu, in that menu there’s an option to “block this domain”
I only use Lemmy for one specific community I passively moderate, so I’m mostly unknowledgeable how Lemmy works for things outside of Lemmy.
I am even unsure how to read this very post from Lemmy since I didn’t post it to a community.😬
I will boost your post so hopefully you can get an answer on whether or not it’s possible for you.
I haven’t blocked it yet
@[email protected] thanks for replying, friend.
I have not either yet.
This latest update gives me hope that it’ll eventually happen, but they are going slower than a fucking sloth…🤦♂️
I’m waiting to see if they’re gonna try to pull some asshattery.
I know what’s theoretically possible with AP and it’s nothing that I can’t undo by blocking their ass, so I’d like to see them try to fuck this up…
Speaking seriously, my instance has already preemptively defederated from threads so there’s nothing left to do for me. Given your username, I’m guessing you’re running your own masto instance so you’re set as well. Really, there’s nothing sneaky to be done. If they decide to make an instance and download all of the personally identifiable information on the lemmyverse, there’s nothing that can be done about it. I know far less about how much personally identifiable information leaks to other masto instances, but if it’s similar, building an advertising profile and ignoring mastodon proper may well be the strategy.
@[email protected] it cannot be done. They can only get anything that’s already public on your profile, nothing more. Emails and IP addresses aren’t shared, and no advertising cookies are ever grabbed from Fediverse that I’ve ever seen.
They can allow companies to make accounts and make posts that are essentially ads, but it cannot be targeted across AP and companies can already do that if they wish on Mastodon.
Your profile name, profile pic, bio, and public posts are what they can get from AP.
@[email protected] Nah, maybe some of my friends who are too hesitant to use Mastodon will use Threads, so I’ll be able to interact with them in my own space. 😅
(Off topic: how’d you post to mastodon and lemmy at the same time? 😳)
@[email protected] well…I didn’t…at least not on purpose.
Apparently Mbin, or at least fedia.io, uses hashtags to make posts in communities.
I added the hashtags and it went without my knowledge or intention.😂🤷♂️
@[email protected] Ohh that’s interesting! I might check out Mbin. Just setup a PieFed account as well.
@[email protected] it’s pretty neat!
The original creator seems like a decent enough person and from my point of view, looks like he’s doing it in a very admirable way by not “holding the keys to the castle” for lack of a better term. Multiple people have merge control for PRs and such. It’s pretty cool.
We had an unfortunate misunderstanding a few weeks ago, but I’d hope that we have corrected that and can leave it in the past and move on.
Hmmm. No. Not yet. I’ll cogitate though.
@[email protected] unfortunately, being on Lemmy, I’m not sure that you could.😬 I didn’t think about Lemmy when creating this because I was not aware that Mbin makes posts based on hashtags. I’m very unknowledgeable about that part of Fedi.
I think the only way you could, as a Lemmy user, would be to migrate or sign up on a different instance that blocks it for you.🤷♂️
Is there an instance I can sign up to that hasn’t blocked it?
One of the reasons I run my own (single-user) pyfedi instance is so I remain empowered to make this choice on my own.
I’m not preemptively blocking Threads but I haven’t decided yet - I’ll leave the default alone and take a wait-and-see attitude.
@[email protected] depends, are you looking for a Mastodon instance?🤔
One of the reasons I move to a single user instance … I don’t block threads
Hugz & xXx
@[email protected] thanks for answering, friend.🙏
i specifically chose my instance because it has them defederated.
@[email protected] that makes sense! Thanks for replying friend.
@[email protected] I don’t block threads on my instance. I limit them because I think as they build out more integration, spammers will begin posting from there, given that it will take longer to remove them on Threads than on a Mastodon server. I have no plans to ever block Threads.
But, I have unlimited many Threads accounts individually, as exceptions, that I know are real and safe, and will do so on request.
@[email protected] that makes sense. I’m on my own here, as you know, so I don’t feel I have much risk here.
I can definitely understand being concerned for their moderation practices though. That’s been one of the most wide concerns.
@[email protected] nope because dor us here in europe the fediverse function within threads is. ot active
@emaechler ahhh…that’s true.
Unfortunately that’s due to GDPR and their inability to insure the deletion of data on request.😬
However, on Fedi, you can still see, follow, and reply to Threads users from other countries if you aren’t blocking them.
So this post is meant more of like “do you have the intention to block threads?”
Like a lot of people have very valid reasons like they’re concerns for moderation and things which is, of course, very valid.
But if your intention is to not block threads right now you should vote no.
@[email protected] why should we block threads? the posts in the fediverse are public - anyone can read them with an rss reader - so there’s no point…
@[email protected] some are worried about getting harassed. LGBTQ folks are among some I’ve seen that are worried.
@[email protected] stupid people find always a way to harass others - and the fediverse has the same insane user as twitter facebook etc …
@[email protected] yes, but moderation on the smaller instances is way better because of the small userbase compared to Threads with 200m+ that I can imagine is harder to moderate, even for a bigger company, things slip through and I understand not wanting to be called slurs because of your sexual preference/race/religion etc.
It’s their choice after all. All I can do is listen and respect their decision.🤷♂️
@[email protected] yes - i will not block it but i am admin from a single user instance 🤣🤣 and yes i dont see the point of blocking…. but perhaps i am playing this social media game too long and have a thik skin 🤣🤣
@[email protected] Essentially single user instance… Well, less “single user” than I expected, as there is “activity” from one account as of about 2 weeks ago.
@jigmedatse me?
If so, they’re both me. The other is an unused account, that I keep logged in, that I made to attach to relay.fedi.buzz which helps me get content to my instance and helps my content go out. It’s called Fedibuzzdummy cause it’s a dummy account for Fedi buzz.
The only other account here is the guy that helped me set the instance up over a year ago and hasn’t been online since that day.
@[email protected] Oh, I meant my instance is basically a single user instance. And blocked at the instance level.
There may be reason to reverse that, but it was based on activity that hit my instance, not just political.
@[email protected] ohhh…I was SO confused😅
Sorry.🤦♂️
You do you. Block whoever you wish for whatever reason you wish. It’s not my place to tell anyone who to block and not block.
I’m just curious about the stats.🤷♂️
@[email protected] Hey, no problem with being confused. I was just letting you know of what the situation was here. No criticism, no suggesting anyone do anything in any direction. Though honestly, I’d be interested to see if Threads might be worth considering unblocking. Or .social (unrelated).
@[email protected] Well, that really depends on you and if you feel you would be safe from harassment, if such things should occur.
I know lots of LGBTQA folks have that worry specifically. I am not familiar with Meta’s moderation, but I’ve seen it said many times that it’s not good.
Take that how you wish. I don’t have such issues, so I feel safe. But I wouldn’t recommend anyone who is a part of those types of communities to let their guard down.
@[email protected] Yeah, I get enough already with instances that shouldn’t really end up being sources of that kind of hate…
@[email protected] yeah…could it be .social?🤦♂️
