I am thinking about building a PC oriented towards music production. My current desktop is 10 years old this month and is due to be replaced. Had been considering a Mac Studio but I am having second thoughts given the significant price difference and Apple’s expensive storage upgrades.

[https://pcpartpicker.com/user/Legonatic/saved/#view=q8MYXL](Link to list)

I use Ableton Live 10 for my DAW. I have a Scarlett 4i4 audio interface, so no need to add any sound card to the build.

Going for a microATX build to save on physical space. Will also likely add another case fan somewhere. No Windows 11 license listed but I intend to get one. GPU is more for any light video editing or Photoshop I might do, not planning to do much of any gaming.

Any suggestions for improvement on this part list or any thoughts in general?

  • @Smokeydope
    link
    5
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    This is the equivalent of vlog youtuber buying a 1500$ Mac to do basic video editing. If your only goal is to do music production you don’t need these kinds of specs. A prebuilt 500$ ibuypowerpc would be more than enough. you can spend the 700$ on some nice equipment and professional software.

    Unless youre a hardcore video gamer or into super specialized tech like locally hosted AI or crypto mining you don’t need to spend more than a few hundred bucks with today’s modern hardware. 8gigs of ram, an amd processor, and a graphics card made in the last 10 years will service you just fine. As a music production person your biggest concern isn’t processing power but hardware fedelity. You want to spend the big bucks on your synth, cabling, production software and sound card if applicable. Also look into open source production programs if you find one that works for your needs you can save bucks that way too.

    • Name is Optional
      link
      English
      110 months ago

      So, the MSI GTX 1650 4Gb is what hardcore gamers are using these days?

      • @Smokeydope
        link
        010 months ago

        I doubt it, hardcore gamers are probably dropping a five grand on the newest 6969 TI special mountain dew edition nvidia card with 8 terrabytes of ram

        • Beefalo
          link
          fedilink
          English
          210 months ago

          Naw, Gamer’s Nexus reviewed that and called it a “waste of sand”, the RX420XX18GB is the shit to have these days

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    210 months ago

    My priority would be to put more resources into the audio interface, controllers, and storage. I think you’ll be fine with just about any modern build. Maybe lean towards the quietest build you can make.

    If you’re serious about your work, I would do a separate drive for storage of your media. Keeping the project data off of the OS drive. I’d even do a backup drive. I don’t think there will be a performance benefit. I just prefer a neat file system. Especially if you’re working with audio clips. Audio files don’t take up a crazy amount of space. I feel it’s important to have backups if you’re collaborating with others.

  • @mrmhm
    link
    110 months ago

    The stock CPU cooler should be okay to start but you might start running into thermal problems after an extended period, especially with heavier multi-track projects. YMMV, but if it’s in the budget it’s nice to have thermal overhead and have it run quieter.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      110 months ago

      I’m honestly surprised that it comes with a cooler with a tdp of 65w while the CPU has a tdp of 219w. I definitely expect some thermal throttling.

    • @LegonaticOP
      link
      110 months ago

      Might go for a better cooler then.

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1
    edit-2
    10 months ago

    I’m not an expert on DAW software, but iirc, it involves loading a lot os small files, so I’d recommend a PCIe gen 4 ssd with high iops. Something like a WD black sn850x or a Samsung 980 pro.

    Also, you should be able to save some bucks on lower wattage PSU. On a side note, what do you need the USB expansion card for? The motherboard comes with some fast USB already. If you do need it, make sure that the slot on the motherboard is electrically wired up with the same amount of PCIe lanes. On an another note, I’m not sure where the sweet spot of ram speed is on intel, but on AMD it is 6000 and Intel is higher than that. So you might want to get some higher speed ram as well.

    • @LegonaticOP
      link
      210 months ago

      I might look into those drives. I was looking at it from more of a price to storage total. I see your point.

      Might go for lower wattage seeing as I could save some money and the overhead is quite high.

      USB card is for all the USB devices I have for music production. MIDI controllers, audio interface, USB connections to synths, plus other devices. Will pay attention to the PCIe lanes.

      I was considering the 6000 ram too.