Hello! I’ve been loving Thunder, but one usability feature I’ve brought over from my days of using Slide (for Reddit) is swiping right (or up, in some cases) to dismiss the post view and return to the feed. This doesn’t work where there are comments, of course, thanks to swipe actions, which I am loving, but it worked on space under them and on the post content itself until the latest update. Is this intended behavior, and will it be coming back? Swiping out of the post creation view still works, which leads me to believe this is generally supposed to work in Thunder.
It works for me but I disabled actions on the LTR swipe for now because I keep accidentally upvoting or downvoting comments when I try to swipe back to my feed. I noticed it takes a specific kind of swipe action for it to work and I need to get used to it to make it repeatable. I don’t upvote/downvote in the first place anyway, so I don’t mind disabling LTR swipe actions.
Turning off the gestures as noted make swiping back out of a post must easier!
Do you happen to have left-to-right swipe comment gestures enabled? There was a change in this latest update which adjusts some logic for this. If you have LTR gestures enabled, then you should be able to swipe from the left edge of the screen to go back. If you have LTR gestures disabled, then you should be able swipe from anywhere on the screen to go back.
If you are still having issues, please create a issue on GitHub so that it can be investigated further!
Ahh, it’s only from the edge of the screen. At that point it’s easier to use the Android back gesture, imo. Maybe it could be changed to allow swiping from anywhere when not on a comment? I don’t know what the code looks like, implementing that might be kludgey.
Edit: Should it be working to swipe back if I swipe from the left edge on a comment, or should that still trigger gestures? Right now it’s triggering gestures, which makes this change seem odd.
Still having a weird thing where if I swipe back a bit, then decide not to go back (release so that it doesn’t go back), and try to again, it takes two attempts, but I assume that’s normal.
Maybe it could be changed to allow swiping from anywhere when not on a comment?
This is something I was messing around with, and it was a bit difficult to get both working at the same time because of conflicting gestures (especially for comments). I can take another go at it and see if I can improve it a bit more though!
Should it be working to swipe back if I swipe from the left edge on a comment, or should that still trigger gestures? Right now it’s triggering gestures, which makes this change seem odd.
This seems like a bug, it should be triggering the swipe back gesture rather than the comment! This is the relevant issue: https://github.com/thunder-app/thunder/issues/302
I have the same problem but think I figured it out. If your finger is in the area that is 1/2 - 3/4” from the left edge, the app will grab the post and you can swipe out. Anywhere else will trigger the up/down votes.
Tried the suggested areas, can’t get it to swipe out since the update
It’s touchy. I laid a ruler on the screen to test various points before I found a spot that worked. The least frustrating work around for now is to turn off the swipe right gestures.