I know I’ll be bombarded with “BEN SCHWARTZ FOR EEL OR NOTHING”. I’m aware that he’s a popular choice, but i wanted to throw in a curveball

I feel like Cory has all it takes to give a spectacular performance as Plas. His performances in SNL and1985 make him able to capture both Eel’s dramatic and comedic sides. He also was in GOTHAM

Even physically, he looks a lot like Plas, he’s attractive but he also has a unique face, plus he’s very long and lean which makes him really fit for stretchy powers