I’ve been using a little bit Cosmic in PopOS on my second computer (MacBook Pro 2012) for around 6 month.
While I like it, I really prefer Gnome for now and would not use it as my daily driver.
It’s a shame because I wanted Cosmic to be Gnome with more customization (I have KDE on my Steam Deck and it’s also not my thing even if it’s efficient).
Here are my biggest annoyances:
You can’t have every app opening at startup on a different workspace (for instance on Gnome I leave empty the first workspace, then Firefox in number 2, thunderbird in number 3, threema in number 4,…)
You can’t switch between workspaces with 3 finger, only with 4
You can’t rename a WebDAV folder in the file explorer and the file disappears after rebooting
You can’t have your battery percentage or it’s duration displayed
It feels like a work in progress and not like something you could really rely on
I’ll check on github if these issues were already reported to the devs, otherwise I’ll do it.
I’m almost thinking about switching my second computer to something, else but I wanna see what Cosmic becomes in the next few years.
What are your annoyances with Cosmic and what do you think about it?
Its my daily driver and I love it. The only real challenges I’ve had have been how they implemented the file browser. After some early challenges back in alpha it got really stable but then recently its been constantly crashing out on me.
My use case is pretty moderate though because I can’t use it for work, so just home use.
Yeah Cosmic Files is also crashing often for me and then I can’t close it to open a new window. I can’t understand what’s trigerring it for bow.
Did you notice improvements over time with Cosmic?
I guess I’ll keep it for at least a year on my second computer because I really want it to progress and succeed at being a middleground between KDE and Gnome.
Cosmic has improved immensely and quickly from where it was in alpha. Major issues for me in those earlier phases were things like steam windows starting partially off screen and the built in media player. They have been quick to fix and I saw some file browser issue reports get opened recently although I need to go and add to the comments. I’m full on with cosmic at this point and have far fewer pain points with it than I did with KDE or gnome.
Gnome style linear virtual desktops rather than 2 dimensional. I’ve had 9 virtual desktops in a 3x3 grid for ages.
I have it a shot briefly, but there are some Gnome extensions that I just can’t go without these days.
Like which?
Genuine curious.
I’m currently using:
- AppIndicator Support
- Astra Monitor
- Dash to Panel
- GSConnect
- Just Perfection
- Media Controls
- No overview at startup
- Tiling Shell
Tiling shell is probably the most important one for me. I have some monitor-specific window layouts that I’m particular to, and Tiling Shell is the only tiling system I’ve found (although admittedly I’ve only tried a couple) that lets me set up what I want, save layouts per monitor, handles monitors powering on and off, and doesn’t completely reset when I log off and on.
Yeah I was also trying to move away from the dependency on extensions because they are sometimes unreliable if you update Gnome too soon and the extension isn’t available for the new version, but Cosmic is way less reliable for now, especially Cosmic Files.



