

The direct federal supremacy argument seems like a long shot to me. For example, the fire code is also enforced by the state of Colorado. Does GEO Group claim to be exempt from the fire code?
There’s a federal law that grants fed contractors protection from state liability when they are performing their federal contracts. But only when they are performing to the fed’s requirements and specifications. Does this law matter here? Is this a “protection from liability” or an “exemption from regulation?” Is it going to matter whether GEO is following the specs or not? I don’t know.











The concept of “stand on” in the international navigation rules is slightly different from right if way as you might apply to a car crash.
I was taught, if you are the “stand on” vessel, you have a duty to maintain steady course and speed. Stay predictable. The last thing the nav rules want is for two vessels to both make course alterations and turn into each other.
I should also add that rule 2 requires all vessels to maneuver when necessary to avoid a collision. Even the stand on vessels.