I’ve been really enjoying John Scalzi’s catalog- Started with Starter Villain (delightful!), The Kaiju Preservation Society (Sweet…), Lock In + Head On (fun who-done-its), The Android’s Dream (clever, enjoyable read), Agent to the Stars (funny, creative, pretty good).

I’m half way through the first book of Old Man’s War and it’s depressing AF. I don’t see how it’s going to get any more light hearted, given the subject matter. All the aliens are enemies, more battle scenes than anything else, graphic descriptions of war injuries and deaths… I’m not really compelled to keep going. Can anyone vouch for it being worth it to continue?

Edit: I’m realizing that “better” isn’t a good descriptor. I guess what I mean is “Will there be fewer graphic descriptions of injuries and death; as well as general despair on the part of the MC.” It is a “good” book by all metrics except “feel-goodiness” and “Not making me queasy at descriptions of faces being blown apart.” I’d come to expect a light and clever romp from John Scalzi, and from everyone’s replies, he is more varied in his styles than I’d previously been aware.

I’d been half hoping this would all resolve into a lovely, heartwarming story about how the universe was saved by a race of benevolent, highly intelligent cats who tricked everyone into getting along. I tried to go further this morning and am, for now going to set it aside after another scene with an exploding face.

Thanks to all who replied!

  • @[email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    417 months ago

    Worth continuing? Absolutely. Getting more lighthearted and fun? Not really. Old Man’s War wasn’t really meant as a lighthearted romp.

      • @I_Fart_GlitterOP
        link
        47 months ago

        That tracks. As someone who takes many steps every day to stave off crushing depression, I try to keep to more fanciful/hopeful fare for my leisure reading. Thanks for your input!

        • @Nouveau_Burnswick
          link
          47 months ago

          The Bobiverse books are in a similar vein, and much more light hearted.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      57 months ago

      I’d say each book ends on a slightly happier note, but I would never call them light-hearted. The humor tends to the grim, and the outcomes are never wonderful.