• Neuromancer
    link
    fedilink
    166 months ago

    There really wasn’t another option for Columbia. It was die in space or die trying to land.

    • Carighan Maconar
      link
      86 months ago

      What about the two alternatives that were forwarded after the accident, either a rescue mission or in-orbit repairs?

      Sure, both were far from a guaranteed success. Far from. Still better than nothing. As in: They were another option than just letting it explode.

      • @Spedwell
        link
        36 months ago

        I thought both of these were actually impossible for Columbia. IIRC the rescue mission was impossible because there were no available vehicles, and the EVA equipment onboard would let them inspect the tiles but they couldn’t actually fix them.

        • Carighan Maconar
          link
          66 months ago

          Atlantis was already scheduled to fly not too long after, and the CAIB discussed that there was a possibility of moving the launch up as Columbia could have stayed an extraordinary long time in orbit due to their specific mission loadout.

          Repairs with harvested tiles were also discussed but yeah , chance of success rated as low. Still, better than deorbiting with nothing done.

        • @DarkCloud
          link
          56 months ago

          NASA has been known to do the impossible from time to time.

      • Neuromancer
        link
        fedilink
        -46 months ago

        Didn’t have the equipment for either.

        We don’t have a rescue ship just sitting around. It’d take months to get one ready.