As part of an analysis of how U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida Judge Aileen Cannon, reports from her courtroom show a judge who is both “prickly” and" insecure" and often has trouble understanding what lawyers from both sides try to explain to her.
The controversial Cannon – who has been accused of slow-walking Donald Trump’s obstruction of justice trial related to his alleged illegal retention of government documents – in recent hearings has pressed lawyers to remake their points over and over, which led to the New York Times’ Alan Feuer to question whether, “she does not understand the answers she is receiving or is trying to push back against them.”
“Only the best,” am I right?
What jurisdiction do you practice in, if you don’t mind asking? I work in one of the bigger trial courts in the United States and have NEVER seen lawyers have to explain a concept like this to any judicial officer I’ve ever worked with across 5 years of trial. Aileen Cannon is a national disgrace.
If your own law clerks have quit on you…you have to be pretty terrible.
https://www.msnbc.com/deadline-white-house/deadline-legal-blog/aileen-cannon-clerks-quit-trump-rcna144490
Yeah this is embarrassing for her, frankly.
You don’t have appeals for stupid things judges do? Well, that sounds nice.
I’m not saying it’s endemic to hear a judge doesn’t know the law in certain situations, but it’s definitely happened. Depending on the judge - a lot.