This ability to edit RCS — not SMS — is rolling out to stable starting today, but all the Google Messages users in a conversation need to have it enabled.

  • Simon Müller
    link
    fedilink
    English
    146 months ago

    The Google-Way of doing things

    Yet another W for Signal where you can edit indefinitely, and can look at the edit history. No context lost, no risk of modifying things after the fact

    • @Solemarc
      link
      English
      56 months ago

      I’m not sure this is a fair comparison, since this is only coming to RCS and not SMS my (completely unsubstantiated) guess would be that this is a message protocol issue.

      On the other hand Signal is an encrypted internet messaging service and editing internet messages has been easy for everyone not named twitter for years.

      • Simon Müller
        link
        fedilink
        English
        55 months ago

        There are ways to do indefinite edits using message relationships

        The edit message would simply refer to the message to be edited and contain the new content, or a delta/diff of the content. This would not need to be shown to the user in the UI

        The reason it’s this fucked up is probably more because it’s yet another Google-Specific extension on top of RCS if I had to make a guess.