• FaceDeer
    link
    fedilink
    -44 months ago

    The Internet Archive was distributing unlimited copies of ebooks whose rights were held by major publishers.

    The major publishers sued them for distributing copies of ebooks whose rights were held by them.

    Yeah, totally unrelated.

    • Flying Squid
      link
      English
      64 months ago

      Me:

      But the lawsuit was about CDL as a whole, not what happened in 2020.

      You:

      Yes, the lawsuit is about CDL as a whole.

      So is it about what happened in 2020 or is it about something public libraries do too?

      For example: https://blc.org/controlled-digital-lending

      • @gaylord_fartmaster
        link
        English
        14 months ago

        You are both speculating about what triggered the lawsuit because the only people that know for sure what triggered the lawsuit are the publishers and they aren’t talking.

        If all public libraries are using CDL and the publishers have only sued IA, who flagrantly violated CDL, and they sued them only 2 months after they started violating the CDL, then that certainly seems like a very possible factor in the lawsuit, right?