Sarah Silverman, Christopher Golden, and Richard Kadrey are suing OpenAI and Meta over violation of their copyrighted books. The trio says their works were pulled from illegal “shadow libraries” without their consent.

  • @SCB
    link
    English
    21 year ago

    That destroys the concept of art a free expression. Every graffiti tagger would owe dues. Art woul become an entry paid guild-like institution

    I know you don’t realize it, but this i dystopian shit.

    It’s such a self-evidently bad idea that people didnt realize you’d need it explained.

    • @Candelestine
      link
      English
      -2
      edit-2
      1 year ago

      No, not necessarily. There is a huge legal difference between creating something for commercial gain vs creating it on a voluntary basis. When someone has monetized something, they are pulling in an income from which they can pay people.

      When someone is doing something on a volunteer or amateur basis, they are not pulling in a similar income. We do stuff like this with our tax system all the time.

      We can also draw a line between formal and informal instruction, all “learning” does not have to be the same, after all. There’s no reason formal artistic training cannot be required to pay an additional fee where self-study does not. We actually already do this with more technical fields, it’s even become a racket–college textbooks. Why do artists get to be exempt?

      edit for spelling

      • @SCB
        link
        English
        2
        edit-2
        1 year ago

        Again, you’re missing the dystopian guild-nature of art that would result from your proposal. I do not understand why this is the hill you want to die on.

        College textbooks are not a racket, but rather a result of monopolization of publishing. Why would you want to limit access further?

        • @Candelestine
          link
          English
          -21 year ago

          Unlike some people, I simply enjoy interesting conversation. Not crusading to change the world by fighting for my beliefs or whatever. I like intellectual exploration and discussion.

          It’s not a “hill” and I’m not “dying”. It’s a conversation. Not my fault if I’m surrounded by internet geeks.

          • @SCB
            link
            English
            21 year ago

            I don’t believe you like conversation when you get so defensive of bad ideas.

            • @Candelestine
              link
              English
              -21 year ago

              There it is again, insulting. Calling me defensive and my ideas bad, but not actually elaborating. I think we’ve found a troll.