• @UnderpantsWeevil
    link
    English
    027 days ago

    Who do you think has more influence over policy? A school administrator or a ministry chairperson?

    • @FlowVoid
      link
      English
      327 days ago

      A university president has more influence than a committee chair.

      • @UnderpantsWeevil
        link
        English
        027 days ago

        What international foreign policy does the President of Columbia set?

        • @FlowVoid
          link
          English
          3
          edit-2
          27 days ago

          The chair of a review committee does not set policy. They simply get a voice in the committee that sends reports that might be read by the people who set policy.

          And influence is not measured solely by committee assignments. Otherwise, Elon Musk would lack any influence.

          • @UnderpantsWeevil
            link
            English
            1
            edit-2
            27 days ago

            The chair of a review committee does not set policy.

            You are mistaken.

            They simply get a voice in the committee that sends reports that might be read by the people who set policy.

            They author the policies that the MPs vote on. Show me a piece of legislation passing through Parliament or an executive level policy decision, and I’ll show you the committee that penned it. The Cass Report is a great example.

            And influence is not measured solely by committee assignments.

            Sure. There’s also money. Guess which job puts you in a better position to take bribes?

            • @FlowVoid
              link
              English
              227 days ago

              They author the policies

              If the chair gets to write policy, what do the other committee members do?

              I’ll show you the committee that penned it

              “All legislation passed through a committee” does not mean “All committee output becomes legislation”.

              • @UnderpantsWeevil
                link
                English
                126 days ago

                If the chair gets to write policy, what do the other committee members do?

                Also write the policies. These documents are enormous and require extensive research to compose correctly.

                “All legislation passed through a committee” does not mean “All committee output becomes legislation”.

                What percentage of legislation does a college president write?

                • @FlowVoid
                  link
                  English
                  226 days ago

                  The same as the percentage of legislation that Elon Musk writes.

                  Influence is more than an opportunity to write legislation. And no, she isn’t going to earn more in “bribes” than the $5 million/yr she earned as university president. Nor will she be provided a 10,000 sqft apartment in Manhattan.

                  • @UnderpantsWeevil
                    link
                    English
                    126 days ago

                    The same as the percentage of legislation that Elon Musk writes.

                    What legislation has Musk authored recently?