• @Legendsofanus
    link
    511 months ago

    Can somebody explain on the purpose of these sites?

    The whole time when I was using reddit I would just upload from my gallery to the app, never had to use an image uploader website, it sounds like a pain to use.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      911 months ago

      That’s because you arrived when reddit already had its image hosting.
      Before you could only upload a link, so you had to find a hosting site.
      It’d be the same if lemmy didn’t have one.
      And in fact it’s like that for me, I didn’t configured pict-rs, so I can’t upload images to my lemmy instance, I need to configure it or use a hosting site.

      • @Legendsofanus
        link
        111 months ago

        Wow image-hosting is a thing. Why don’t they just have something so essential out of the box, is it expensive or something

        • Choco1ateCh1p
          link
          10
          edit-2
          11 months ago

          It requires a lot of storage space. Much more than for just text.

          Also, additional liability for hosting images uploaded by literally anyone, that could depict abuse, or be copyrighted.

          • @Legendsofanus
            link
            211 months ago

            Ahh so if somebody did that, the blame would fall on the site that has the image posted

        • @thecdc1995
          link
          211 months ago

          Short answer is yes. Long answer is that with text it’s much easier to stamp out illegal activity because keyword searches are cheap while semantic searches in images are pretty good but extremely computationally expensive. You can’t just scan for illegal activity in images the same way you can nigh instantly scan a body of text for “illegal-site.com”.

          • @Legendsofanus
            link
            111 months ago

            That makes a certain kind of sense but does that mean the filtering algorithm Facebook uses that targets NSFW photos in posts and group chats is very complicated and expensive? is it important for a site like reddit or Lemmy to scan for illegal activities oj a photo?

    • LollerCorleoneOP
      link
      fedilink
      -20
      edit-2
      11 months ago

      Using them do add one or two extra steps before posting. Images can hog up server resources and using these third-party sites reduces the burden for the server of your instance which is run by volunteers/hobbyists with money often coming from their own pockets. Its just a nice thing to voluntarily do.

      • decadentrebel
        link
        211 months ago

        On the other hand, it’s great that some instances have file size limits. It forces users to look at these image hosts instead of them just recklessly uploading images into the servers as if Lemmy is housed in a Palo Alto facility.