• Resol van Lemmy
    link
    English
    324 months ago

    Pronouns are a basic part of language. Getting rid of them makes communication way harder. Unless you speak Spanish, I guess.

      • Resol van Lemmy
        link
        English
        84 months ago

        I know they exist, it’s simply the fact that they’re not usually required in daily speech, since verb conjugation gives the context of the pronoun anyway.

        • @lugal
          link
          74 months ago

          For subject pronouns, object pronouns are obligatory

            • @madcaesar
              link
              64 months ago

              The pronouns were asking for it, wearing that skirt!

          • @CoggyMcFee
            link
            34 months ago

            Even subject pronouns are certainly used in everyday speech, even if less often compared to English.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          14 months ago

          Yes, they are required and used. First, verb conjugation has nothing to do with object pronouns. You always need those. Second, subject pronouns may not always be required but are used much more often than they are omitted.

          It’s not good practice to comment with such confidence when you’re so wrong.

    • @toynbee
      link
      34 months ago

      Spanish pronouns are used mainly in the plain.

      (Side note: I thought the original quote was something like “the rain in Spain falls mostly on the Spaniards,” but I can’t find anything to support that. Only today did I even learn that it was from a song.)

        • @toynbee
          link
          2
          edit-2
          4 months ago

          Apparently, “The Rain in Spain.” (To be clear, I would not have known that before looking it up to verify the quote.)

          The original lyric I was parodying was “the rain in Spain falls mainly on the plain.” (Which, again, I would have gotten wrong if I hadn’t researched it.)

          edit: After a few minutes reviewing YouTube videos, apparently it was prose recited by the protagonist of “My Fair Lady,” the movie from which that song came. Eventually she gained confidence via that song.

          I don’t know, I previously lacked context for the quote, but after watching a relevant video I realize I’ve seen a parody of it in Family Guy.

          • 🐍🩶🐢
            link
            English
            24 months ago

            And My Fair Lady is a remake based on the 1938 Pygmalion. I actually like the 1938 version better. All and all, Pygmalion is a play written by George Bernard Shaw back in 1912/1913.

            • @toynbee
              link
              24 months ago

              And then, in 2000, the culmination of all that effort and culture: Pygmoelion.

            • @toynbee
              link
              14 months ago

              I added more context to my original response. Hope you enjoy it!