If any significant number of community members are opposed to this, we can discuss it further.

Judging by the reactions to the recently-posted, now-removed NMS AI content, it seems it’s generally poorly-received and people (including me) would prefer it not to be featured in this community.

  • @NMSGalacticHubOPM
    link
    1
    edit-2
    2 months ago

    not all AI content is actually bad

    I disagree, and judging by the -10 points on the only AI content ever posted here, it seems others do as well. If you find a compelling example of AI content which wouldn’t be widely detested, maybe we could make an exemption if the community agrees with you.

    Seems like lazy moderating.

    I have no problem being lazy at an unpaid job, so my advice on that front is to suck it up.

    • @QuadratureSurfer
      link
      English
      2
      edit-2
      1 month ago

      You saw a single low quality post made with Generative AI and all of a sudden want to ban any image that has even a little bit of AI used in it?


      Edit: I just double checked the updated community rules and saw that you left exceptions for AI background removers and AI Upscaling. Thank you for at least considering minor uses of AI.

      Edit 2: I’m not a fan of how you accuse others of not being a part of the community. A lot of us are lurkers here and upvote comments/posts in this community and only comment/post when something really piques our interest. Are you saying that we’re not a part of this community? This was one of the first communities I ever subscribed to…


      I understand making a rule if it becomes a problem with a bunch of low quality posts spamming the place, but this just feels like a knee jerk reaction because of your disdain for anything related to AI (although it’s worth pointing out that the DLSS option in No Man’s Sky is using AI models to improve quality/boost fps).

      If you find a compelling example of AI content which wouldn’t be widely detested, maybe we could make an exemption if the community agrees with you.

      Alright, here’s an example of some really cool AI generated content: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMRi6pNAoag

      The way I see it, generative AI is going through some early phases similarly to how cameras were treated in the past. Photographers, for a long time, weren’t regarded as artists for a while simply because it was so easy to just go out and take a picture of anything. But even photography can vary from the random cell phone pictures that anyone can take to the prize winning photographers that capture an amazing moment or who spend a lot of time getting the composition just right for the shot that they want to take. They might even wait in a specific spot for hours just to get a picture when the sun is at the right position.

      Likewise with AI generated content, it’s easy to quickly create a lot of junk. But there are artists out there that use AI as another tool in their belt in addition to everything else that they have learned.

      • @NMSGalacticHubOPM
        link
        0
        edit-2
        1 month ago

        I’ll respond to this with what I said to one of the other AI-enthusiast-non-NMS-players commenting here:

        I brought up this topic to gauge the general response from members of this community - I absolutely am not interested in discussing AI content as a concept with AI enthusiasts or other people who are not members of this community.

        Also, the example you linked is completely unrelated to No Man’s Sky. Unsurprisingly. So that doesn’t apply here at all.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      02 months ago

      I find it interesting that you brought this subject up for discussion but you seem to not actually be interested in discussing it and rather just shitting on AI content. Which is fine, I don’t really have a horse in this race as I’m not subbed here and don’t really care for NMS that much. But just know that you are a lazy disingenuous person from where I’m sitting.

      • @NMSGalacticHubOPM
        link
        11 month ago

        No worries, that couldn’t matter less to me. I brought up this topic to gauge the general response from members of this community - I absolutely am not interested in discussing AI content as a concept with AI enthusiasts or other people who are not members of this community. You’re right about that part.