If water flowing over continents in rivers is what concentrates salt in our ocean, would a planet that has always been covered in water just be freshwater? The water is just sitting there, not eroding through salts.

  • @HotDayBreezeOP
    link
    310 hours ago

    I was trying to figure out how much underwater erosion there is but if you compare the sandy and silty bottom of the ocean to like, Utah, it seems like continental erosion is orders of magnitude more significant.

    Conversely, we know oceans deposit all sorts of stuff at their bottoms, which makes me think there is a small amount of salt being deposited. Would that cancel out significant underwater erosion?

    Similarly, if underwater erosion was a big deal, wouldn’t old lakes (in geological time) be notably saltier than young lakes? But the only salty lakes we have primarily lose all their water through evaporation, basically ultra concentrated river water.

    • @SzethFriendOfNimi
      link
      710 hours ago

      There’s also heat exchange so you’ll have deep sea vents where there could be all kinds of caustic stuff and/or minerals.

      So it wouldn’t necessarily be fresh even if that stuff wasn’t saline

      • @neatchee
        link
        39 hours ago

        For those following along: SEAWATER IS NOT SALINE EITHER. Just making sure we’re clear on everything

          • @neatchee
            link
            28 hours ago

            Hahaha I figured something like but couldn’t resist the opportunity :D