• @Lumisal
    link
    English
    -34 months ago

    Shooting down a nuclear icbm doesn’t really help as much as you think, if it catches it.

    Not to mention the atmosphere lighting up wouldn’t be much better

    • @Madison420
      link
      English
      124 months ago

      You know they don’t go critical when you shoot them right?

      • @Lumisal
        link
        English
        -24 months ago

        Doesn’t that depend on how they’re set up? I’d imagine in the 50+ years since they’ve been invented they would have designed it so it could, specifically because modern anti missile defenses exist.

        I mean, I know world governments can be dumb, but I would imagine they’re not that dumb as to bother maintaining a key super weapon just to not upgrade it / design it so that it won’t work if used.

        • @Madison420
          link
          English
          34 months ago

          Maybe but no not really the triggering process is extremely fast but kinda fragile because everything needs to be compressed just so.

          They upgrade them, it’s public knowledge for the budget. Usually it’s faster smaller or different form factor plus renewal programs.

          • @Lumisal
            link
            English
            04 months ago

            But any knowledge on how modern triggering works on them I’d imagine would be kept a state secret wouldn’t it? I don’t think it’s something you’d want others to know.

            • @ricdeh
              link
              English
              24 months ago

              Someone has to know because scientists and engineers are educated in universities and not in military boot camps. Universities are the origin of all scientific expertise in a nation, including the nation’s military.

              • @Lumisal
                link
                English
                04 months ago

                They hid the Manhattan project really really well, if you’ve ever looked into the history.

                • @[email protected]
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  1
                  edit-2
                  2 months ago

                  That was 80 60 years ago.

                  The knowledge required to design ignition systems is from the thousands of people who’ve gone through, or are currently in, universities.

                  Plus, the physics, and challenges, haven’t changed.

                  It’s a different game now.