• @ramenshaman
    link
    English
    107 days ago

    That’s not how percentages work

    • @NorthWestWind
      link
      English
      3
      edit-2
      6 days ago

      Say, there exists 2 humans and 98 bacteria. Consider all cells of a human one life.

      50% of ALL life doesn’t care which species the life is, and therefore there’s a chance that 50 bacteria die. The probability of that happening is 98C50 / 100C50 = 98! 50! 50! / (100! 50! 48!) = (50)(49) / ((100)(99)) = 0.247

      For my previous argument, I did not actually do the math. Now that I have done a little bit, the probability seems to converge at 25%

      Obviously, this is based on the interpretation of “all life”. For my interpretation, “all life” includes every life in a single set, and apply the 50% snap to that. For some others however, it may be interpreted as each species in their own set, and the 50% snap is applied on each set individually.

      • @ramenshaman
        link
        English
        16 days ago

        But if there are 7 billion humans and n bacteria, and 50% of them are snapped, wouldn’t approximately 3.5 billion humans and n/2 bacteria be snapped?

        • @NorthWestWind
          link
          English
          16 days ago

          The problem is the ambiguity of the statement. Is it 50% of each species? Or is it 50% of all life as one set?

          If it’s the former case, then sure 3.5b humans and n/2 bacteria gets snapped.

          But if it’s the latter case, we group all 7b and n bacteria into one set and snap half of them. This 50% can consist of 50% humans + 50% bacteria, but there’s also a chance for it to include 0% humans + 100% bacteria. Therefore, the amount of humans snap is a random variable instead of a constant.

    • enkers
      link
      fedilink
      English
      7
      edit-2
      7 days ago

      Moreover, that’s not how probability works in independent events.

      It’d be like saying “I flipped coin A 1 billion times and got half a billion heads, so now that I’m flipping coin B 100 times, I probably won’t get any more heads.”

      It should be fairly obvious that you can say the exact same statement about tails, and get a completely contradictory statement.