This is the first time I’m seeing a way to host a full Bluesky network, I think. It seems like a big step towards full federation beyond appviews and personal data servers.

  • @solrize
    link
    English
    2519 hours ago

    There is already a fediverse twitalike called mastodon. I don’t understand why anyone here cares about bluesky.

    • @Docus
      link
      English
      2015 hours ago

      Because mastodon is the Linux of social media. One day it will be ready for the average user…

      • Marud
        link
        fedilink
        English
        813 hours ago

        2025 is the year of Linux Desktop Mastodon

      • @solrize
        link
        English
        1819 hours ago

        By that logic we should also connect up with facebook and 4chan, not to mention twitter itself. bsky is just another one of those platforms from what I can tell. It is fairly new so not yet blatantly evil, but give it time. We here are supposed to know better.

        • Communist
          link
          fedilink
          English
          313 hours ago

          bluesky is foss and open to federation, why not bluesky? Also a mastodon bluesky bridge is possible because of this as well

          • @solrize
            link
            English
            613 hours ago

            It’s not about the code, it’s about control of the servers and feeds. Decentralization doesn’t just mean multiple servers. It means no single entity has special authority over the user community. That isn’t the case with bluesky from what I can tell.

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              68 hours ago

              You are correct, if you take a step back and consider bluesky wholistically, it is DEFINITELY not decentralized.

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          516 hours ago

          By that logic we should be happy gazing at our own navels, shouting to the void, looking at empty pages.

    • @iopq
      link
      English
      818 hours ago

      Because it doesn’t have search (at least my instance doesn’t), doesn’t show engagement so the whole thing feels empty like people are posting into the void

      • @solrize
        link
        English
        -316 hours ago

        If the problem is fixable technical shortcomings, why not fix them instead of throwing up our hands and surrendering?

        • @[email protected]
          link
          fedilink
          English
          713 hours ago

          As a Linux user since 2007 I feel a little dirty uttering this phrase, but:

          Because not everyone is a developer.

          • @solrize
            link
            English
            013 hours ago

            You don’t have to be a developer to use Lemmy, yet it has similar features to reddit including search. Maybe there are sociological issues in growing its userbase, but not serious technical ones, as Usenet showed 40 years ago.

            It sounds like mastodon still has technical issues . If Lemmy’s were solvable, mastodon’s are too. Otherwise, how did mastodon get built in the first place?

            • @[email protected]
              link
              fedilink
              English
              613 hours ago

              Just clarifying because I feel we’re talking past each other:

              You asked the folks in this discussion:

              If the problem is fixable technical shortcomings, why not fix them instead of throwing up our hands and surrendering?

              to which I said

              Because not everyone is a developer.

              to which you said

              You don’t have to be a developer to use Lemmy

              True. But that’s not what where we’re at in the discussion.

              It sounds like mastodon still has technical issues . If Lemmy’s were solvable, mastodon’s are too. Otherwise, how did mastodon get built in the first place?

              I’m quite sure they are solvable, but likely not by the folks complaining about the technical issues and choosing to use other services like bluesky. Because not everyone is a developer.

              So in other words, I think your musing out loud about why don’t we solve the issues instead of giving up and using something else is being directed to the wrong people.