I want to say we agreed that the base had to be out of Earth’s orbit. I’d have to go over the details again as we made the wager a long time ago and after several drinks.
Does a moon base count? Technically the moon would have orbital priority but it itself or its the Earth. Does an aldrin cycler count as a base? Does something in an unstable orbit that happens to largely coincide with earths orbit count?
No on the moon base as the Nazis already did it. The base needs to be installed on a terrestrial body other than Earth and its moon. Just to keep things fair since we’re unsure how long it might be before the fabric of time is discovered to require military intervention.
Thats a meaningless distintion, the moon orbits the earth with an elliptical orbit in the Earth’s frame of reference, or an eliptical orbit with fairly large, low frequency oscillations in the Sun’s frame of reference. The same is true for something in LEO except the oscilations are smaller and shorter period.
Out of curiosity, would you consider a LEO space station to be off-planet or not?
I want to say we agreed that the base had to be out of Earth’s orbit. I’d have to go over the details again as we made the wager a long time ago and after several drinks.
Does a moon base count? Technically the moon would have orbital priority but it itself or its the Earth. Does an aldrin cycler count as a base? Does something in an unstable orbit that happens to largely coincide with earths orbit count?
No on the moon base as the Nazis already did it. The base needs to be installed on a terrestrial body other than Earth and its moon. Just to keep things fair since we’re unsure how long it might be before the fabric of time is discovered to require military intervention.
Base on moon would not be orbiting the earth because the moon does not orbit the earth.
Wut? The moon definitely does orbit the earth, that’s like its defining feature. Am I whooshing?
We’ve been getting mooned this whole time?!
https://youtu.be/KBcxuM-qXec?si=uAEbhcRMlEhZCwCD
They explain it well
Earth and Moon both follow circular orbits around the sun
The moon is not traditionally orbiting the earth like the space station does
https://youtu.be/KBcxuM-qXec?si=uAEbhcRMlEhZCwCD
They explain it well
Earth and Moon both follow circular orbits around the sun
The moon is not traditionally orbiting the earth like the space station does
Thats a meaningless distintion, the moon orbits the earth with an elliptical orbit in the Earth’s frame of reference, or an eliptical orbit with fairly large, low frequency oscillations in the Sun’s frame of reference. The same is true for something in LEO except the oscilations are smaller and shorter period.
It is a valid distinction
Remove the sun and the moon and earth will no longer be together. Either the moon is leaving or crashing into the earth.
Remove the sun and the ISS is still going to orbit the earth.
If we were driving cars around a race track and kept pass each other on the left, you’d say one of us was “orbiting” the other?
I’m not sure where you got that from, the moon absolutely is gravitationally bound to the earth, so much so that it has become tidally locked.
E: from your own link https://youtu.be/KBcxuM-qXec?t=182
Is this the new conspiracy theory to replace flat earth? Go, spread your narrative wings!
https://youtu.be/KBcxuM-qXec?si=uAEbhcRMlEhZCwCD
They explain it well
Earth and Moon both follow circular orbits around the sun
The moon is not traditionally orbiting the earth like the space station does