I need support in understanding if I’m a spammer or not. First I thought to put it into [email protected] but now I’m really afraid to post into the wrong community and get banned from it too, so I decided to go to this support community, I hope I won’t get banned here for that.

Yesterday I saw this article online: https://www.wired.com/story/red-note-tiktok-xiaohongshu/ which has the title “With a TikTok Ban Looming, Users Flee to Chinese App ‘Red Note’” and thought to myself: “Haha, that sounds like an article the Onion would write! The government trying to protect the people from the Chinese by banning TikTok and the people run to the next Chinese app, it really sounds like satire.” and then I remembered that we have a community on Lemmy called “Not the Onion” [email protected] and thought to myself “The people in this community will probably enjoy this irony that it sounds like a The Onion article but it’s real life and not satire.”. That’s when I decided to post it there, here is the original post: https://piefed.jeena.net/post/97462 (I’m not sure if other Admins can see it).

I’m copying the rules to post there from that community for your convenience:

The Rules Posts must be: Links to news stories from… …credible sources, with… …their original headlines, that… …would make people who see the headline think, “That has got to be a story from The Onion, America’s Finest News Source.”

  1. Wired is a credible source
  2. the headline is the original headline
  3. It made at least me think “That has got to be a story from The Onion”

Anyway, I went to sleep and when I woke up I had a notification saying: " You have been banned from Not The Onion" I went to the post and saw that it’s deleted too and that it has -22 in votes. Ok, clearly people didn’t like it for some reason which is not very clear to me. The comments there did not indicate any reasons, they just made fun of the same thing I thought was funny.

I looked into the modlog and can see there:

[email protected] Banned account Jeena in Not The [email protected] Reason: Spammer

Now the thing which stuns me, am I really a spammer? I’m following the rules and I’m posting something which in my mind really fits into the community but I am now banned and can’t even read posts in that community in my feed flow.

Full disclosure, I have been banned from a different community on a different server before, it was on [email protected] and I commented as an answer to someone saying “The tankies did good things, the fought the nazis.” I wrote “Just to turn around and do the same to their own people.” which then has been deemed that I’m antisemitic and should be banned from that community forever. Their reasoning was that with this sentence I express that Jews were not Germans, which I was not, I didn’t even mention what the nazis did.

  • [email protected]
    link
    fedilink
    16
    edit-2
    3 days ago

    Yesterday I saw this article online: https://www.wired.com/story/red-note-tiktok-xiaohongshu/ which has the title “With a TikTok Ban Looming, Users Flee to Chinese App ‘Red Note’”

    But then the title of the post that was removed was this:

    GET DIGITAL ACCESS Already a subscriber? Sign In Zeyi Yang Business Jan 13, 2025 3:03 PM With a TikTok Ban Looming, Users Flee to Chinese App ‘Red Note’

    The extra first bit does kinda read like spam or maybe a messed copy paste or something.

    • JeenaOP
      link
      fedilink
      English
      63 days ago

      Aah, yeah when I copy and pasted the title this was there and I didn’t realize only after I posted it. But then I changed the title and removed the bold part, did it not propagate to the other instances?

      • JeenaOP
        link
        fedilink
        English
        93 days ago

        I checked on the Wired website and when I start marking the title all of that gets automatically marked and copied to copy and paste. I guess it’s some javascript doing that at least in Firefox.

        Ok that explains finally the reason, thanks for pointing that out.

        • @kescusay
          link
          English
          123 days ago

          I did indeed see “GET DIGITAL ACCESS” and hit the ban hammer immediately because it looked like spam. I will unban your account, and you are welcome to re-post the story (with the correct headline).

          • JeenaOP
            link
            fedilink
            English
            113 days ago

            Ok, good to know, thanks for your understanding.

            But that also sounds to me that my change of the title, which I did about 30 seconds after I posted the post, never made it from my PieFed instance to your Lemmy instance. This seems be a bug somewhere in one of the software, I will create a bug fot PieFed so it can be investigated.

            • @kescusay
              link
              63 days ago

              No problem. I’m actually just sorry it happened.

              • @s38b35M5
                link
                English
                13 days ago

                This is why we need to ask the good questions, people. Good post; good result!

      • @s38b35M5
        link
        English
        13 days ago

        BTW, some mobile apps (I use Voyager) can retrieve the title for you in the new post submission UI.

    • @[email protected]
      link
      fedilink
      English
      33 days ago

      It was a messed up copy and paste. The article author is Zeyi Yang, the category is Business. And the rest probably came from some hidden content in his viewport when copied to the clipboard.

      I don’t blame whoever did ban though, hopefully they’re willing to reverse it.