• threelonmusketeers
    link
    fedilink
    English
    1910 hours ago

    its mass will go up hugely, meaning the force provided to a small pellet will barely move it any further

    But since the ring is at the end of the barrel, all of the force has already been applied to the pellet. I supposed to crux of the matter is whether the shrunken pellet has its original mass or not, and whether momentum or velocity is conserved upon transformation.

    • @rtxn
      link
      2210 hours ago

      The limiting factor is not force or velocity but energy. If the pellet retains its original mass, the kinetic energy imparted by the explosion won’t be enough to propel it to any kind of useful distance. If the pellet’s mass drops proportionally to its size, the explosion will accelerate it to a sufficient velocity, but upon exiting the barrel, the sudden increase in mass means it would have to shed a lot of its velocity to conserve its kinetic energy.

      Truly, the question is whether magic can violate the laws of thermodynamics, and how that would affect entropy.

      • Pennomi
        link
        English
        69 hours ago

        the question is whether magic can violate the laws of thermodynamics

        Well obviously it can, it’s magic and can do all kinds of dumb things. Like, go through the Player’s Handbook and tell me which spells DO rigorously follow scientific principles. It’s a pretty short list.

      • threelonmusketeers
        link
        fedilink
        English
        59 hours ago

        the sudden increase in mass means it would have to shed a lot of its velocity to conserve its kinetic energy

        Do we have a reason to believe that a magic ring would conserve kinetic energy, rather than momentum or velocity?

      • @joel_feila
        link
        510 hours ago

        Well either phyisic is getting bent over the tabel. If ke is mantianed as the mass return them it screw up momentum, which is also something that is conserved irl. If the momentum is conserved the keis violated