I don’t believe free will is real. I’m not a deep physics person (and relatively bad at math), but with my undergrad understanding of chemistry, classical mechanics, and electromagnetism, it seems most rational that we are creatures entirely controlled by our environments and what we ingest and inhale.

I’m not deeply familiar with chaos theory, but at a high level understand it to be that there’s just too many variables for us to model, with current technology, today. To me that screams “god of the gaps” fallacy and implies that eventually we WILL have sufficiently powerful systems to accurately model at that scale…and there goes chaos theory.

So I’m asking you guys, fellow Lemmings, what are some arguments to causality / hard determinism, that are rooted entirely in physics and mechanics, that would give any credit to the idea that free will is real?

Please leave philosophical and religious arguments at the door.

  • @A_A
    1•9 months ago

    At what point does the causal chain get interrupted ( … ?)

    The system is diverging at every point in time :

    In chaotic systems, the uncertainty in a forecast increases exponentially with elapsed time. (… same article from Wikipedia)

    I believe one has to see this before being able to apply it to free will explanations.

    • @grabyourmotherskeys
      1•9 months ago

      So, at what point is your personal decision making controlling the divergence so that it reflects your will? That is what I am asking.

      • @A_A
        1•9 months ago

        at what point ( … ? )

        Before answering this I need to know if you get the basics : what do you understand so far ? About chaotic systems ? About their variable rate of exponential divergence ? About their “liberty” ? About the fact we have such systems in us, only far more complex ?

        And beyond any explanations, if you came to know we have free will, how could we stand the shame and guilt of not doing enough ?

          • @A_A
            1•9 months ago

            It’s something I think about constantly, whether I want to or not! ;)

            When I was young I was in that situation, with those same questions. But I was lucky : I had the right science and the right IQ and I found the answers. You are now thirsty and I gave you some salt ; if you are too blind to see it or too arrogant, bad for you, so i will not come back to this.

            Goodbye.

            • @grabyourmotherskeys
              0•9 months ago

              You still haven’t answered the question and have made at least a couple of inferences about me that aren’t really accurate.

              Anyway, people say it you can’t explain it you don’t understand it

              Edit: sorry, wrong thread. I would still say you are making lot of assumptions.

              How old do you think I am? Let’s start with that. :)