• Shadow_KID
    link
    fedilink
    211 year ago

    @dinckelman @CosmicSploogeDrizzle Black/White were the best games that the series had. I still don’t understand all the hate for these games to this day. The world was great, the postgame was good, and the Pokémon weren’t designed as poorly as everyone says.

    • @TwilightVulpine
      link
      English
      111 year ago

      Because nostalgia is a driving force for this franchise and BW committed the sin to dare not to rely on that. Which is why even when they cut the National Dex in Sword and Shield, they made sure nobody would miss that Charizard was still there.

      They are constantly testing how little they can offer and still have people buy out of sheer nostalgia. That Indigo Disk DLC with the Blueberry Academy looks like it will be very barebones, just an enclosed environment with some Elite 4-like fights, but they made sure to show that all the old starter buddies are back, because they know people will flock to that.

      • dinckel
        link
        English
        21 year ago

        My issues are exactly as you’ve described. Selling a top shelf product with as little effort as possible, and with as little content as possible.

        But the biggest issue I’ve had really consists of the content the games have now. It doesn’t feel like an adventure anymore. There is not thrill from discovery, or going to a new area where things might beat you up, while you’re exploring and trying to find a way forward. Your hand is held all the way through, you’re being told exactly what to do, and even if you lose, the game still lets you go through. It’s just plain not fun anymore, for me personally

        • @TwilightVulpine
          link
          English
          41 year ago

          Pokémon was never too challenging but one thing I think people overlooked is that the end of HMs killed a lot of exploration potential and puzzles.

      • @Squiddy
        link
        English
        01 year ago

        BW on it’s own really were unimpressive and I understand the hate they recieved. Coming right after Platinum and HGSS left them with big shoes to fill that those games just couldn’t. Not that they were bad, just not on par with what came before. What saved Gen5 was BW2, and personally changed my stance on BW. Both together make the best experience Pokemon ever had.

        • @TwilightVulpine
          link
          English
          21 year ago

          I haven’t played enough Platinum to say for sure, but that doesn’t sound right to me at all. BW alone was a very good game already.

          • @Squiddy
            link
            English
            11 year ago

            Platinum added and changed so much that it’s still considered the definitiv Gen4 version, even after BDSP released. It’s really that different.

            • @TwilightVulpine
              link
              English
              31 year ago

              So I hear, but also that DP was really flawed before it. BW was pretty good by itself.

    • dinckel
      link
      English
      21 year ago

      Enjoyment of something is completely subjective, but I personally just did not enjoy a lot of the design and style choices in these games. The Pokemon didn’t feel very exciting, and it just felt like they were running out of ideas quickly. I can understand why people enjoyed B/W and the 2’s, but unfortunately I did not

    • @Zanshi
      link
      English
      11 year ago

      TBF those had to grow on me, especially the first ones. They were actually challenging, due to changes in how exp gain is scaled. Plethora of activities after the game ends is something that got me hooked for a long time in Black 2, which overall I think I enjoyed a lot more than 1

    • @Squiddy
      link
      English
      01 year ago

      What excactly was so great about the postgame? The right side of unova didn’t had that much to offer. Kyurem, Cynthia, the dive maze, the roaming genie and Looker are the only noteworthy things that come to mind.

      • Shadow_KID
        link
        fedilink
        31 year ago

        @Squiddy I liked that you could catch only gen 5 pokemon before the postgame, which is why you can later build a completely new team and warm up with the new pokemon. to the were the other cities made interesting. A small highlight was the white forest

        • @Squiddy
          link
          English
          31 year ago

          Not gonna lie, only having new pokemon for the story was a welcome change. It’s a reason why Ruby and Saphire are so memorable to me, you only encountered new pokemon for the first few hours. I agree that the White Forest (and Black City) are beautiful places, tho I have to say that I prefer the BW2 versions because of the “rogue-like” facility.